Editors Reads Verdict
A sensory feast of a book — the food writing is superb, the landscape description is lyrical, and Mayes's pleasure in the life she has chosen is infectious. Less structured than Mayle but more poetic in register.
What We Loved
- The food writing — market visits, recipe experiments, seasonal ingredients — is among the best in the genre
- Mayes writes as a poet, and the descriptive prose has a warmth and precision that journalism-trained writers rarely achieve
- The renovation detail is specific and practical without being dry
- The integration of recipes throughout the narrative makes the book useful as well as enjoyable
Minor Drawbacks
- Less structurally coherent than A Year in Provence — the book can feel like a collection of essays rather than a continuous narrative
- The unrelenting beauty of the setting occasionally makes the book feel like an extended daydream
- Some readers find the lack of conflict or difficulty makes the narrative too placid
Key Takeaways
- → Restoration work connects you to a place's history in ways that new construction cannot
- → Italian markets operate as a form of social intelligence — what is available tells you what season it actually is
- → The rhythm of daily life in rural Tuscany — meals, walks, work, rest — is itself a form of education
- → Speaking a language poorly is not an obstacle but a method of learning
| Author | Frances Mayes |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Broadway Books |
| Pages | 280 |
| Published | January 1, 1996 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Travel, Memoir, Food Writing |
| Difficulty | Beginner |
| Best For | Readers drawn to Italian life and culture, food writing, and renovation memoirs — particularly those who have fantasised about a farmhouse in Tuscany and want either to plan it or to experience it vicariously. |
Frances Mayes was teaching creative writing at San Francisco State University and recently divorced when she and her partner Ed Kleinschmidt drove into the Tuscan hills above Cortona and saw a stone villa that had been abandoned for thirty years. They bought it on impulse — Bramasole, they named it, from the Italian for “yearning for sun” — and began the renovation and the writing that produced Under the Tuscan Sun. Published in 1996 and adapted into a film in 2003 (which changed almost everything about the story), the book was on the New York Times bestseller list for two and a half years and became the defining document of the Tuscany fantasy for an entire generation of readers.
Mayes writes as a poet, and the register of the book is lyrical where Mayle’s A Year in Provence (its obvious predecessor) is comic. Her descriptions of the landscape — the changing light across the Val di Chiana, the exact green of the olive grove in September, the smell of a cellar full of previous seasons — achieve a precision that most travel writers attempt and few manage. She is also excellent on food, and Under the Tuscan Sun is threaded throughout with recipes and market scenes that document the Tuscan relationship between season, soil, and table as it actually functions rather than as tourist literature presents it. The fennel sausage made by the local butcher, the exact variety of tomato that tastes right for a particular sauce, the difference between olive oil pressed in October and oil pressed in November — these details accumulate into a portrait of a food culture that has not lost contact with its origins.
The renovation sections are among the book’s most quietly instructive passages. Mayes discovers that restoring a three-hundred-year-old Tuscan villa requires not just tradesmen but an understanding of how the building was originally constructed — with techniques, materials, and principles that have not changed in centuries. A local mason who repairs a wall using the original lime mortar rather than cement explains that cement traps moisture and destroys the original stonework; the old method allows the wall to breathe. These are not anecdotes about Italian inefficiency; they are lessons in the intelligence embedded in traditional craft.
Under the Tuscan Sun is looser in structure than A Year in Provence — it reads less as a single sustained narrative than as a series of essays and observations from multiple visits over several years. Some readers find this formlessness relaxing; others find it makes the book hard to finish. Mayes’s pleasure in her adopted landscape is real and unironic, and the book’s lasting appeal is rooted in that authenticity. She genuinely loves the place she is writing about, and the love is particular enough — specific to Cortona, to Bramasole, to the specific quality of Tuscan afternoon light — to transfer to readers who have never been there and may never go.
Reading Guides
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "Under the Tuscan Sun" about?
Frances Mayes, a poet and university professor, buys a ruined villa in the Tuscan hills, restores it with her partner Ed, and discovers the rhythms of Italian rural life — its food, its seasons, its ancient craftsmanship, and its unhurried beauty.
Who should read "Under the Tuscan Sun"?
Readers drawn to Italian life and culture, food writing, and renovation memoirs — particularly those who have fantasised about a farmhouse in Tuscany and want either to plan it or to experience it vicariously.
What are the key takeaways from "Under the Tuscan Sun"?
Restoration work connects you to a place's history in ways that new construction cannot Italian markets operate as a form of social intelligence — what is available tells you what season it actually is The rhythm of daily life in rural Tuscany — meals, walks, work, rest — is itself a form of education Speaking a language poorly is not an obstacle but a method of learning
Is "Under the Tuscan Sun" worth reading?
A sensory feast of a book — the food writing is superb, the landscape description is lyrical, and Mayes's pleasure in the life she has chosen is infectious. Less structured than Mayle but more poetic in register.
Ready to Read Under the Tuscan Sun?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: