Editors Reads

Best Mystery Books

Mystery fiction is built on a promise: if you read carefully enough, you can solve the case before the detective does. The best mysteries keep that promise while making the journey as enjoyable as the destination.

See our full guide to the best mystery books →

243 expert-reviewed books — page 1 of 11

Editorial Top Picks

Mystic River book cover
BestsellerEditor's Pickliterary fiction

Mystic River

by Dennis Lehane

4.6

Three boys from the Flats in East Buckingham, Boston. When they are eleven, Dave Boyle is pulled into a car by two men and held for four days. Twenty-five years later, Jimmy Marcus's daughter Katie is found murdered. Sean Devine, now a state police detective, investigates. Dave is a suspect.

Rebecca book cover
BestsellerEditor's Pick

Rebecca

by Daphne du Maurier

4.5

A young woman marries the brooding Maxim de Winter and moves to his grand estate Manderley, where the memory of his glamorous first wife Rebecca poisons every room and every relationship.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
The Round House book cover
BestsellerEditor's Pick

The Round House

by Louise Erdrich

4.5

Joe Coutts, thirteen years old, watches his mother return from a violent assault on an Ojibwe reservation in North Dakota. The attacker cannot be prosecuted because of a jurisdictional tangle: the crime may have occurred on tribal land, federal land, or state land, and each has different rules about who can prosecute. Joe sets out to find justice himself.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
The Power of the Dog book cover
BestsellerEditor's Pick

The Power of the Dog

by Don Winslow

4.4

DEA agent Art Keller's decades-long war against the Sinaloa Cartel, from the 1970s through 9/11. A massive, novelistic account of the Mexican drug trade — cartel politics, US government corruption, CIA involvement, and the human cost on both sides of the border.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
The Hot Zone book cover
BestsellerEditor's Pick

The Hot Zone

by Richard Preston

4.3

Richard Preston's harrowing true account follows the 1989 appearance of a lethal strain of the Ebola virus in a primate research facility in Reston, Virginia—just outside Washington, D.C.—and traces the virus's earlier outbreaks in Central Africa, where it killed with near-total lethality. It is one of the most terrifying science books ever written.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
A Brief History of Seven Killings book cover
BestsellerEditor's Pick
4.2

The attempted assassination of Bob Marley in Kingston, Jamaica in December 1976 is the still point around which this vast, polyphonic novel turns — following gang members, CIA operatives, journalists, and ghosts across three decades and multiple continents in dense, overlapping Jamaican voices.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
Shantaram book cover
BestsellerEditor's Pick

Shantaram

by Gregory David Roberts

4.2

An escaped Australian convict arrives in Bombay with a false passport, becomes a slum doctor, makes friends and enemies among the city's criminals, and discovers a city that unmakes and remakes him completely.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
Under the Banner of Heaven book cover
BestsellerEditor's Pick
4.1

A double narrative: the murder of a Mormon woman and her infant daughter by fundamentalist brothers who believed they were acting on divine revelation, intertwined with the full history of the Latter-day Saint movement from Joseph Smith to the present day. A rigorous examination of religious fundamentalism and faith.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
The Luminaries book cover
BestsellerEditor's Pick

The Luminaries

by Eleanor Catton

4.0

A mysterious death, a missing fortune, and a damaged woman bring twelve men together in a Hokitika hotel on the New Zealand West Coast in 1866. Catton's structurally extraordinary novel uses astrological charts to determine its form, with each section exactly half the length of the previous one.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
Say Nothing book cover
Editor's Pick

Say Nothing

by Patrick Radden Keefe

4.8

The story of the Troubles in Northern Ireland, told through the abduction and murder of Jean McConville and the lives of IRA members Dolours Price and Gerry Adams.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
The Hound of the Baskervilles book cover
Editor's Pick

The Hound of the Baskervilles

by Arthur Conan Doyle

4.8

A spectral hound haunts the Baskerville family across the Dartmoor moors, and when the new baronet arrives to claim his inheritance, Holmes sends Watson ahead while working in secret. Conan Doyle's masterpiece fuses gothic atmosphere with rigorous detective logic into the most complete and satisfying Holmes story.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
Gone Baby Gone book cover
Editor's Pick

Gone Baby Gone

by Dennis Lehane

4.4

Private detectives Patrick Kenzie and Angela Gennaro are hired to investigate the disappearance of a four-year-old girl from a Boston neighbourhood. The case pulls them into drug trafficking, police corruption, and a moral dilemma at the end that has no right answer.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
The Likeness book cover
Editor's Pick

The Likeness

by Tana French

4.4

Detective Cassie Maddox is pulled back into undercover work when a murder victim is found bearing her exact face — and carrying the identity Cassie once used as an alias.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
Black and Blue book cover
Editor's Pick

Black and Blue

by Ian Rankin

4.3

Rebus investigates a murder that connects to the unsolved Bible John killings of the 1960s while simultaneously investigating the oil industry in Aberdeen and a copycat killer. The book that won the Gold Dagger and established Rebus as a major series.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
Darkness, Take My Hand book cover
Editor's Pick

Darkness, Take My Hand

by Dennis Lehane

4.3

Kenzie and Gennaro are hired to protect a psychologist who has received death threats from a patient. As they investigate, they are drawn into a twenty-year pattern of murders in Dorchester and Charlestown — and into personal danger that will alter the series permanently.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
Brighton Rock book cover
Editor's Pick

Brighton Rock

by Graham Greene

4.2

Brighton, the 1930s. Pinkie Brown is a seventeen-year-old gang leader, a Catholic who believes in damnation and acts accordingly. After a murder, he marries Rose, a waitress who could testify against him, intending to kill her after she can no longer be called as a witness. Ida Arnold, a cheerful hedonist, pursues him. Greene's darkest and most theologically exact novel.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
Missing Person book cover
Editor's Pick

Missing Person

by Patrick Modiano

4.2

A private detective named Guy Roland discovers he has no past—his memory was erased, and even his name is a fiction. He begins investigating his own identity, tracing himself through prewar and wartime Paris to discover who he was before the amnesia. Winner of the Prix Goncourt. Modiano's most emblematic novel.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
Motherless Brooklyn book cover
Editor's Pick

Motherless Brooklyn

by Jonathan Lethem

4.2

Lionel Essrog has Tourette's syndrome and works for a small Brooklyn detective agency run by Frank Minna. When Frank is murdered, Lionel — compelled by tics, verbal eruptions, and the inability to leave a pattern unresolved — investigates his mentor's death. A genre novel about the detective impulse as a form of neurological necessity.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
The Daughter of Time book cover
Editor's Pick

The Daughter of Time

by Josephine Tey

4.2

Inspector Grant, bedridden after an accident, investigates the murder of the Princes in the Tower — a 400-year-old cold case. Voted the greatest mystery novel of all time by the Crime Writers' Association, Tey's intellectual detective story is a meditation on history, rumour, and how received narratives harden into fact.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)

Frequently Asked Questions

Disclosure: Amazon links on this page are affiliate links. If you purchase through them we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Skip to main content