Editors Reads Verdict
Erdrich's National Book Award winner and her most plot-driven novel — the thriller mechanics are real and the mystery is genuinely compelling, but the underlying subject is the legal framework that makes violence against Native American women almost unpunishable.
What We Loved
- The jurisdictional complexity is explained clearly and is genuinely infuriating — the political argument is made through narrative rather than polemic
- Joe's voice is perfectly calibrated: thirteen, intelligent, limited in ways that are precisely right
- The thriller structure gives the political subject a forward momentum it would lack as straight fiction
Minor Drawbacks
- Some readers want more from the female characters, who are somewhat peripheral to Joe's quest narrative
- The ending requires Joe to do something that will sit differently with different readers
Key Takeaways
- → The Violence Against Women Act's provisions for tribal jurisdiction were specifically designed to address the problem Erdrich dramatises — the novel helped build political pressure for reform
- → A thirteen-year-old's pursuit of justice is both understandable and tragic — the adults who should be acting are paralysed by the same jurisdictional confusion
- → Reservation poverty and federal neglect are the context within which individual violence becomes systematic
| Author | Louise Erdrich |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Harper Perennial |
| Pages | 321 |
| Published | October 2, 2012 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Literary Fiction, Crime Fiction, Native American Fiction |
| Difficulty | Beginner |
| Best For | Readers new to Erdrich who want her most accessible and propulsive novel, and literary fiction readers interested in Native American justice and sovereignty. |
The Attack
Joe Coutts’s mother Geraldine is the tribal enrollment judge on the Ojibwe reservation near Pluto, North Dakota. One spring afternoon she drives out to the church and does not come back for hours. When she does, she is changed — she will not leave her bedroom, will not speak about what happened. The family doctor tells Joe’s father Bazil, who is the tribal court judge, that Geraldine was raped.
Bazil begins the legal investigation and hits the wall almost immediately: the attack may have occurred on tribal land, on federal trust land, or on state land, and the rules about who can prosecute — tribal court, federal court, or state court — are different in each jurisdiction, and the overlapping claims create a legal space in which nothing can be done. The attacker knows this.
The Legal Argument
Erdrich wrote The Round House partly in response to the ongoing crisis of violence against Native American women, who are assaulted at rates far exceeding the national average and whose attackers — particularly non-Native attackers — face dramatically lower prosecution rates because of jurisdictional complications that federal law created and has been slow to repair.
The political argument is made entirely through Joe’s story — we experience the impotence of Bazil’s legal position through Joe’s perspective, and the solution Joe arrives at is the one that the law cannot take but a thirteen-year-old boy can. This is not triumphant. It is the novel’s deepest subject.
Our rating: 4.5/5 — Erdrich’s most accessible and urgent novel: a genuine thriller with a genuine political argument, and one of the best American novels of the 2010s.
Reading Guides
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "The Round House" about?
Joe Coutts, thirteen years old, watches his mother return from a violent assault on an Ojibwe reservation in North Dakota. The attacker cannot be prosecuted because of a jurisdictional tangle: the crime may have occurred on tribal land, federal land, or state land, and each has different rules about who can prosecute. Joe sets out to find justice himself.
Who should read "The Round House"?
Readers new to Erdrich who want her most accessible and propulsive novel, and literary fiction readers interested in Native American justice and sovereignty.
What are the key takeaways from "The Round House"?
The Violence Against Women Act's provisions for tribal jurisdiction were specifically designed to address the problem Erdrich dramatises — the novel helped build political pressure for reform A thirteen-year-old's pursuit of justice is both understandable and tragic — the adults who should be acting are paralysed by the same jurisdictional confusion Reservation poverty and federal neglect are the context within which individual violence becomes systematic
Is "The Round House" worth reading?
Erdrich's National Book Award winner and her most plot-driven novel — the thriller mechanics are real and the mystery is genuinely compelling, but the underlying subject is the legal framework that makes violence against Native American women almost unpunishable.
Ready to Read The Round House?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: