Editors Reads Verdict
Erdrich's most structurally complex novel — the multigenerational reveal is handled with enormous skill, and the original injustice gains weight with each narrative layer. Longlisted for the Pulitzer.
What We Loved
- The multigenerational structure is handled with extraordinary skill — each narrator adds information that recontextualises what came before
- The original crime and the lynching are rendered with restraint that makes them more rather than less devastating
- The title image — a biblical plague of doves that strips every crop in the region — establishes the novel's mythic dimension
Minor Drawbacks
- The novel's complexity demands active tracking of characters and relationships across generations
- Some of the later narrators are less fully realised than the central figures
Key Takeaways
- → Historical injustice — particularly racial violence — does not dissolve over generations but propagates through the families and communities it touches
- → The original narrative assigned to an event is rarely the true one, and the gap between them is where the novel lives
- → Small communities maintain their secrets and their myths simultaneously, and the relationship between the two is never simple
| Author | Louise Erdrich |
|---|---|
| Publisher | HarperCollins |
| Pages | 313 |
| Published | April 1, 2008 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Literary Fiction, Native American Fiction |
| Difficulty | Advanced |
| Best For | Readers who want Erdrich's most structurally ambitious work, or anyone interested in how novels can accumulate truth gradually across multiple narrators and generations. |
The 1911 Murder
The novel opens with what everyone in Pluto, North Dakota knows: that in 1911, a white farm family was murdered, that three Ojibwe men were accused, and that those men were lynched before trial. What everyone knows is, of course, incomplete. Evelina Harp, the granddaughter of one of the lynched men, is the novel’s central contemporary narrator — but she is one of several, distributed across the decades between 1911 and the present.
Erdrich’s structure is intricate. Chapters alternate between narrators, time periods, and families — the Harp family, the Coutts family, the Wildstrand family — and the reader gradually assembles the full picture from partial accounts. The structure is not decorative but argumentative: the truth about the original murders only becomes visible when enough perspectives are assembled, and each narrator provides a piece the others lack.
The Plague
The title refers to an actual historical phenomenon — the population explosions of mourning doves that occasionally descended on North Dakota in the early 20th century and stripped fields clean. Erdrich uses it as an opening image of natural force that recognises no human boundaries, neither the reservation lines nor the property lines that organise the world the novel inhabits.
The Plague of Doves was longlisted for the Pulitzer Prize in 2009. It is among the most formally accomplished novels in a career that prizes formal complexity.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "The Plague of Doves" about?
A murder in 1911 — a white family killed on their farm, blame assigned to three Ojibwe men who are lynched — haunts a North Dakota town for generations. Multiple narrators across several decades gradually reveal the truth behind the original murders and the lynching, and the consequences that have propagated through every family in the area.
Who should read "The Plague of Doves"?
Readers who want Erdrich's most structurally ambitious work, or anyone interested in how novels can accumulate truth gradually across multiple narrators and generations.
What are the key takeaways from "The Plague of Doves"?
Historical injustice — particularly racial violence — does not dissolve over generations but propagates through the families and communities it touches The original narrative assigned to an event is rarely the true one, and the gap between them is where the novel lives Small communities maintain their secrets and their myths simultaneously, and the relationship between the two is never simple
Is "The Plague of Doves" worth reading?
Erdrich's most structurally complex novel — the multigenerational reveal is handled with enormous skill, and the original injustice gains weight with each narrative layer. Longlisted for the Pulitzer.
Ready to Read The Plague of Doves?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: