Editors Reads

Best Mystery Books

243 expert-reviewed books — page 2 of 11

The Yiddish Policemen's Union book cover
Editor's Pick
4.2

In an alternative history, Jewish refugees settled in Sitka, Alaska after World War II instead of Palestine. Now the Federal District of Sitka is about to revert to Alaskan jurisdiction, and detective Meyer Landsman has a body in his hotel room and a chess piece near the corpse. A genre novel that is also a meditation on home, diaspora, and the limits of belonging.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
If We Were Villains book cover
Editor's Pick
4.0

Seven Shakespeare students at a prestigious arts conservatory navigate obsession, rivalry, and moral collapse until one of them turns up dead after a production of Othello — narrated a decade later from a prison cell.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
Lying in Wait book cover
Editor's Pick

Lying in Wait

by Liz Nugent

4.0

Dublin judge Andrew Fitzsimons and his wife Lydia kill a young woman named Annie and must maintain their respectable life while concealing the crime — told from multiple unreliable perspectives including Lydia's chilling first-person narration.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
The Intuitionist book cover
Editor's Pick

The Intuitionist

by Colson Whitehead

4.0

Lila Mae Watson is the first Black female elevator inspector in a segregated American city. When an elevator she has certified in good order falls in free-fall, she becomes a suspect in a larger conspiracy involving the city's two warring schools of elevator inspection: the Empiricists and the Intuitionists.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
A Small Death in Lisbon book cover
Editor's Pick

A Small Death in Lisbon

by Robert Wilson

3.9

Two investigations fifty years apart — a contemporary Lisbon detective uncovering a murdered girl's story, and a German SS officer managing Portugal's wartime wolfram trade — whose threads converge in a single act of historical violence.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
Bangkok 8 book cover
Editor's Pick

Bangkok 8

by John Burdett

3.8

Thai detective Sonchai Jitpleecheep investigates the murder of an American Marine in Bangkok — a case involving jade smuggling, exotic snakes, and the city's sex industry, narrated with Buddhist equanimity and dark humour.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes book cover
Bestseller
4.9

Twelve stories from The Strand Magazine collected into the first Holmes short story anthology, including A Scandal in Bohemia, The Red-Headed League, and The Speckled Band. The short story format reveals Conan Doyle's genius at compression — twelve complete puzzles delivered at full intensity.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
Bad Blood book cover
Bestseller

Bad Blood

by John Carreyrou

4.6

Wall Street Journal reporter John Carreyrou tells the complete story of how Elizabeth Holmes and Theranos defrauded investors and endangered patients with a blood-testing technology that didn't work.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
The Shadow of the Wind book cover
Bestseller

The Shadow of the Wind

by Carlos Ruiz Zafón

4.6

In postwar Barcelona, a young boy discovers a mysterious novel by a nearly forgotten author, and his obsession with the book's creator leads him deep into a dark labyrinth of secrets, loves, and betrayals.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
I'll Be Gone in the Dark book cover
Bestseller

I'll Be Gone in the Dark

by Michelle McNamara

4.5

The late Michelle McNamara chronicles her obsessive investigation into the East Area Rapist, later called the Golden State Killer — a serial criminal who terrorized California in the 1970s and 80s.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
The Devil in the White City book cover
Bestseller
4.5

The intertwined stories of the 1893 Chicago World's Fair — one of the most ambitious construction projects in American history — and the serial killer H.H. Holmes, who used the fair's crowds as cover for his murders.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
A Fatal Grace book cover
Bestseller

A Fatal Grace

by Louise Penny

4.4

The most hated woman in Three Pines is found dead at the village curling match, electrocuted in a sealed outdoor space — and Chief Inspector Gamache discovers that almost everyone had reason to want her dead.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
Ocean Prey book cover
Bestseller

Ocean Prey

by John Sandford

4.4

Lucas Davenport and Virgil Flowers investigate a drug smuggling operation off the Florida coast that is leaving federal agents dead — a crossover entry between Sandford's two major series.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
Piranesi book cover
Bestseller

Piranesi

by Susanna Clarke

4.4

A man lives alone in a vast, labyrinthine House of endless halls filled with statues, tides, and clouds, keeping meticulous journals of a world he believes to be complete — until anomalies in his journals suggest a truth he has been prevented from remembering.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
Still Life book cover
Bestseller

Still Life

by Louise Penny

4.4

Chief Inspector Armand Gamache of the Sûreté du Québec investigates the suspicious death of a beloved woman in the idyllic village of Three Pines.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
The Lincoln Lawyer book cover
Bestseller

The Lincoln Lawyer

by Michael Connelly

4.4

Criminal defense attorney Mickey Haller operates out of the back seat of his Lincoln Town Car, traveling between Los Angeles courthouses. When a wealthy Beverly Hills client hires him to fight a serious assault charge, Haller begins to suspect the man is guilty of something far worse — and that he has defended it before.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)
Big Little Lies book cover
Bestseller

Big Little Lies

by Liane Moriarty

4.3

Three mothers in an Australian coastal community navigate school politics, marriage, friendship, and the fallout from a murder at the kindergarten trivia night.

Check Price on Amazon (paid link)

Disclosure: Amazon links on this page are affiliate links. If you purchase through them we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Skip to main content