Editors Reads Verdict
The Rebus novel that won the CWA Gold Dagger and announced Rankin as the pre-eminent voice of Scottish crime fiction — the ambition here (three interlocking investigations, a meditation on Scotland's oil economy, the ghost of Bible John) is matched by the execution.
What We Loved
- The three-investigation structure is managed with genuine control — the connections are organic rather than contrived
- The Aberdeen/oil industry material gives the novel a political-economic dimension unusual in crime fiction
- Rebus's relationship to the Bible John case — his obsession with an unsolvable crime — deepens his characterisation significantly
Minor Drawbacks
- The complexity requires patience — this is not a novel that can be read inattentively
- Some prior knowledge of the Rebus series is useful, though not strictly necessary
Key Takeaways
- → The Bible John murders are Scotland's most famous unsolved case — their presence in the novel connects contemporary crime to a specific kind of national trauma
- → The Aberdeen oil economy brought wealth and instability to Scotland in ways that are still being felt — the novel uses the industry as a political mirror
- → Rebus's persistence on cases that cannot be solved is both his defining quality and his fundamental problem
| Author | Ian Rankin |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Orion |
| Pages | 394 |
| Published | January 1, 1997 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Crime Fiction, Mystery |
| Difficulty | Beginner |
| Best For | Readers of British crime fiction — best read after Knots and Crosses, but accessible as a standalone for those willing to pick up context as they go. |
Three Investigations
Rebus is assigned a murder investigation. The victim appears connected to the Bible John killings — a series of Glasgow murders in the late 1960s that were never solved. A copycat killer is operating in Aberdeen. The oil industry is implicated. Rankin manages these three threads with the control of a novelist who has found his full range.
Black and Blue won the CWA Gold Dagger, the top prize in British crime fiction. The award recognised what the novel represented: not just a superior thriller but a serious literary achievement that used the crime genre to examine Scottish society, economy, and history.
Scotland’s Ghost
Bible John — the killer who murdered three women after meeting them at Glasgow’s Barrowlands dance hall — is Scotland’s version of Jack the Ripper: a name without a face, a crime without resolution. Rankin uses the case as Rebus uses it: as an obsession, a symptom of something in Scottish culture that the country has not been able to confront.
Our rating: 4.3/5 — The Rebus novel that made the series — ambitious, complex, and fully realised.
Reading Guides
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "Black and Blue" about?
Rebus investigates a murder that connects to the unsolved Bible John killings of the 1960s while simultaneously investigating the oil industry in Aberdeen and a copycat killer. The book that won the Gold Dagger and established Rebus as a major series.
Who should read "Black and Blue"?
Readers of British crime fiction — best read after Knots and Crosses, but accessible as a standalone for those willing to pick up context as they go.
What are the key takeaways from "Black and Blue"?
The Bible John murders are Scotland's most famous unsolved case — their presence in the novel connects contemporary crime to a specific kind of national trauma The Aberdeen oil economy brought wealth and instability to Scotland in ways that are still being felt — the novel uses the industry as a political mirror Rebus's persistence on cases that cannot be solved is both his defining quality and his fundamental problem
Is "Black and Blue" worth reading?
The Rebus novel that won the CWA Gold Dagger and announced Rankin as the pre-eminent voice of Scottish crime fiction — the ambition here (three interlocking investigations, a meditation on Scotland's oil economy, the ghost of Bible John) is matched by the execution.
Ready to Read Black and Blue?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: