Editors Reads Verdict
Barnes's most politically serious novel — the Shostakovich portrait is a sustained meditation on the price of survival under totalitarianism and the compromises that survival requires. Short, exact, and devastating.
What We Loved
- The historical research is thoroughly absorbed — the portrait feels like understanding, not reconstruction
- Barnes's controlled prose is perfectly suited to Shostakovich's careful, watchful consciousness
- The political argument — that survival is not cowardice but a different kind of courage — is made without sentimentality
Minor Drawbacks
- The brevity means some readers want more of Shostakovich's musical life and less of his political life
- The three-structure (1936/1949/1960) can feel schematic
Key Takeaways
- → Survival under totalitarianism requires compromises that look like cowardice from outside and feel like cowardice from inside — and may be neither
- → Art made under constraint is not necessarily lesser art — the constraint becomes part of what is being expressed
- → The musician who outlives the tyrant outlives the silence too — the noise of time is, eventually, the music
| Author | Julian Barnes |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Knopf |
| Pages | 193 |
| Published | January 1, 2016 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Literary Fiction, Historical Fiction |
| Difficulty | Intermediate |
| Best For | Readers of serious literary fiction interested in the relationship between art and political power, and anyone interested in Shostakovich and Soviet cultural history. |
The Lift Landing
In 1936, Shostakovich is one of the most celebrated composers in the Soviet Union. His opera Lady Macbeth of the Mtsensk District has been condemned in Pravda — an unsigned editorial, probably by Stalin himself — as “muddle instead of music.” He is waiting for arrest. Each night he waits by the lift on his landing, suitcase packed, so that he will be taken without waking his family.
He is not arrested. The reprieve is not an acquittal but a postponement — an ongoing threat that shapes the rest of his life. Barnes’s novel follows Shostakovich through three pivotal encounters with Soviet power, asking what these encounters cost him and what they produced.
The Question of Cowardice
Shostakovich signed letters condemning political prisoners. He joined the Communist Party. He accepted the chairmanship of the Union of Composers. He did these things as the price of survival — for himself and for his family. Barnes is interested not in condemning him for these accommodations but in understanding what they felt like from the inside: the specific texture of compromise chosen under mortal threat.
The novel’s title comes from one of Shostakovich’s own phrases for what he heard when he composed — the noise of time pressing on him from all directions.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "The Noise of Time" about?
Three moments in the life of composer Dmitri Shostakovich: waiting by the lift in Leningrad expecting arrest in 1936; meeting NKVD officer Vsevolod Power in Washington in 1949; accepting the chairmanship of the Union of Soviet Composers in 1960. A meditation on what art costs when the state controls your life.
Who should read "The Noise of Time"?
Readers of serious literary fiction interested in the relationship between art and political power, and anyone interested in Shostakovich and Soviet cultural history.
What are the key takeaways from "The Noise of Time"?
Survival under totalitarianism requires compromises that look like cowardice from outside and feel like cowardice from inside — and may be neither Art made under constraint is not necessarily lesser art — the constraint becomes part of what is being expressed The musician who outlives the tyrant outlives the silence too — the noise of time is, eventually, the music
Is "The Noise of Time" worth reading?
Barnes's most politically serious novel — the Shostakovich portrait is a sustained meditation on the price of survival under totalitarianism and the compromises that survival requires. Short, exact, and devastating.
Ready to Read The Noise of Time?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: