Editors Reads Verdict
Flawed, incomplete, and magnificent — Ellison's posthumous second novel was assembled from forty years of manuscript and bears the marks of incompletion, but the central relationship between Reverend Hickman and the man he raised is among American fiction's most morally complex creations, and the prose at its best matches Invisible Man.
What We Loved
- Reverend Hickman is among the most complex and fully realized characters in American fiction — a moral centre of extraordinary weight
- The central conceit — a Black minister who raised a white child who became a racist senator — is one of the most charged situations in the literature
- The prose at its best is the equal of Invisible Man — Ellison's language never diminished over forty years
- The meditation on American identity and the question of what we owe those who raised us is profound
Minor Drawbacks
- The novel is clearly incomplete — the editing by John Callahan, however skilled, shows the seams
- The narrative structure is fragmented and some sections feel like drafts rather than finished prose
- The political and theological arguments are sometimes allowed to run at greater length than the fictional action can support
- A subsequent editor's version (Three Days Before the Shooting) published more of the manuscript, making this edition feel partial
Key Takeaways
- → Race in America is not simply a matter of biology but of culture, upbringing, and the relationships that form identity
- → The man who repudiates those who made him is not thereby free of them — he carries them, transformed into hatred
- → American political corruption is rooted in the denial of the country's mixed origins — racial purity as political ideology requires the suppression of actual American history
- → The preacher's sermon is the central American rhetorical form — the place where the gap between American promise and American practice is most directly addressed
| Author | Ralph Ellison |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Vintage |
| Pages | 368 |
| Published | June 1, 1999 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Literary Fiction, African American Literature, Political Fiction |
Forty Years of Manuscript
Ralph Ellison worked on his second novel for forty-two years. He began it in the late 1950s, showed sections to friends and readers over the following decades, described its scope in interviews, and never completed it. When he died in 1994, he left behind thousands of pages of manuscript, some of it on hard drives damaged in a house fire in 1967, some in folders and boxes. His literary executor, John Callahan, assembled from this material the version published in 1999 as Juneteenth — approximately four hundred pages representing one coherent narrative thread from a much larger, never-finished work.
The story Callahan extracted concerns two men and their long, broken relationship. Senator Adam Sunraider — born Bliss, raised as Black, now a white supremacist politician — has been shot on the Senate floor by a Black man, and lies dying. At his bedside comes the Reverend Alonzo Hickman, the jazz musician turned Baptist minister who raised Bliss from an infant and has come, after decades of silence, to watch over the man his child became. As Sunraider drifts in and out of consciousness, the novel moves between the dying man’s memories and Hickman’s vigil, reconstructing the childhood that formed Bliss and the betrayal by which he became Sunraider.
Reverend Hickman
The moral weight of the novel rests on Hickman, and it is not misplaced. He is among American fiction’s great creations: a large, warm, sonorous man who has lived fully — musician, lover, wanderer — and found in the Baptist ministry a form adequate to his gifts. His sermons, which Ellison renders at length with the full music of the Black preaching tradition, are the novel’s rhetorical peaks. He raised Bliss because a dying white woman asked him to and because Hickman, being Hickman, could not refuse a child who needed raising.
The fact that the child he raised became a race-baiting senator is the novel’s central wound. Hickman does not hate Sunraider. He mourns him — mourns the Bliss he knew, and mourns the country that made the transformation possible. His presence at the deathbed is both a reckoning and a last act of the love that the senator has spent his career denying. It is, as a moral situation, one of the most complex in the literature.
An Incomplete Achievement
The editorial note must be made: Juneteenth as published is not the novel Ellison was writing. It is a portion of that novel, assembled with skill and care but bearing the marks of incompletion — sections that trail off, arguments that are begun and not resolved, characters who appear and disappear without the development the larger work would have given them. The 2010 publication of Three Days Before the Shooting presented more of the manuscript and gave a clearer picture of Ellison’s ambitions, which were enormous.
But even incomplete, Juneteenth contains passages — Hickman’s sermons, the childhood scenes on the revival circuit, the dying senator’s fragmentary memories — that justify the forty years and the wait.
Our rating: 4.0/5 — Flawed by its incompletion but magnificent in its ambition — the portions that work are equal to anything Ellison wrote, and Reverend Hickman is a creation that justifies the novel on his own.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "Juneteenth" about?
A white senator who was raised as a Black child by a Black preacher in the American South is shot on the floor of the Senate and, as he lies dying, remembers his childhood with Reverend Hickman. Ellison's posthumously published second novel — assembled from forty years of manuscript — is flawed and incomplete but contains passages equal to anything in Invisible Man, and the central figure of the Black minister who raised a white child is among the most complex moral situations in American fiction.
What are the key takeaways from "Juneteenth"?
Race in America is not simply a matter of biology but of culture, upbringing, and the relationships that form identity The man who repudiates those who made him is not thereby free of them — he carries them, transformed into hatred American political corruption is rooted in the denial of the country's mixed origins — racial purity as political ideology requires the suppression of actual American history The preacher's sermon is the central American rhetorical form — the place where the gap between American promise and American practice is most directly addressed
Is "Juneteenth" worth reading?
Flawed, incomplete, and magnificent — Ellison's posthumous second novel was assembled from forty years of manuscript and bears the marks of incompletion, but the central relationship between Reverend Hickman and the man he raised is among American fiction's most morally complex creations, and the prose at its best matches Invisible Man.
Ready to Read Juneteenth?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: