Editors Reads Verdict
This Is How You Lose Her is technically Díaz's most controlled work — nine stories that constitute a unified examination of how masculine self-sabotage operates, with prose shifts between registers timed with the precision of a musician.
What We Loved
- The second-person narration of the title story is one of the most effective uses of that mode in contemporary fiction
- The prose is at its most controlled — every register shift is precisely timed
- The portrait of Yunior's self-knowledge alongside his incapacity to change is psychologically exact
- The collection works as a unified whole — the stories illuminate each other
Minor Drawbacks
- The subject matter — male infidelity — may exhaust readers' sympathy before the collection ends
- Yunior's self-awareness about his behaviour can feel like a substitution for actual change
- Some stories feel like coda to *Oscar Wao* rather than standalone achievements
Key Takeaways
- → Self-awareness is not sufficient for self-correction — knowing why you do something does not stop you doing it
- → Dominican machismo is a set of behaviours passed down as damage, not chosen as a character
- → The second person in fiction can function as a form of self-accusation — 'you' is often 'I'
- → Love is most accurately understood as something men destroy rather than something they fail to find
| Author | Junot Díaz |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Riverhead |
| Pages | 213 |
| Published | September 11, 2012 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Short Stories, Literary Fiction, Latino Literature |
This Is How You Lose Her Review
This Is How You Lose Her appeared in 2012, sixteen years after Drown and five years after The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao — a relatively sparse output for a writer of Díaz’s reputation, which created an unusual situation in which the collection was received as a major event. It is, in fact, Díaz’s most formally accomplished work: nine stories that function as a unified examination of a single question, executed with a technical control that the earlier collections, for all their brilliance, did not quite sustain throughout.
The question is: how does a man who can see exactly what he is doing — who can narrate his own infidelities with precision, who knows the cultural formation that produced his behaviour, who understands what he is losing — continue to do it anyway? Yunior, across most of these nine stories, is that man. He cheats on every woman he loves with a compulsiveness that is presented not as villainy but as a kind of structural incapacity — machismo not as a choice but as a language he was taught before he could refuse it.
The title story, narrated in the second person, is the collection’s technical showpiece: “you” is Yunior, but “you” is also the reader, implicating everyone who has ever done the version of this they were capable of. The second person works here as an act of self-accusation: Yunior talking to himself in the mode of self-examination, the “you” creating a distance from the behaviour that cannot quite be maintained. The other stories vary their distance from the same material — some earlier in Yunior’s life, some involving his brother rather than himself — and the cumulative effect is of watching a man circle a problem he cannot solve.
The prose is the achievement that most distinguishes this collection from Drown. The code-switching is present but more precisely controlled, the shifts between registers — formal to colloquial, English to Spanish, past to present — timed with the ear of a musician who knows exactly when to change key and why. This Is How You Lose Her is the book of a writer in full command of his instrument, applying that command to the most personal material he had yet attempted.
Our rating: 4.2/5 — Díaz’s most technically controlled work — a unified examination of masculine self-sabotage told with formal precision and considerable honesty.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "This Is How You Lose Her" about?
Nine stories, most narrated by Yunior, about the serial infidelity that destroys his relationships. Díaz's second collection extends the world of Drown and Oscar Wao into a sustained examination of masculinity, Dominican machismo, and the specific ways men sabotage the love they need.
What are the key takeaways from "This Is How You Lose Her"?
Self-awareness is not sufficient for self-correction — knowing why you do something does not stop you doing it Dominican machismo is a set of behaviours passed down as damage, not chosen as a character The second person in fiction can function as a form of self-accusation — 'you' is often 'I' Love is most accurately understood as something men destroy rather than something they fail to find
Is "This Is How You Lose Her" worth reading?
This Is How You Lose Her is technically Díaz's most controlled work — nine stories that constitute a unified examination of how masculine self-sabotage operates, with prose shifts between registers timed with the precision of a musician.
Ready to Read This Is How You Lose Her?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: