Editors Reads Verdict
A more philosophically interesting book than Old Man's War — Scalzi uses the Ghost Brigades concept to ask genuine questions about identity and what it means to be a person, while delivering everything fans of the first book want.
What We Loved
- The identity question — is Jared Dirac the same person as Charles Boutin whose consciousness he carries? — is handled with real philosophical care
- The Ghost Brigades concept is more original than the Old Man's War premise and generates more interesting story territory
- Scalzi's wit and readability are intact — this is science fiction that works as pure entertainment while smuggling in serious ideas
Minor Drawbacks
- Readers who haven't read Old Man's War will miss the full context, though the novel stands reasonably well alone
- The resolution of the traitor plotline is less surprising than the philosophical setup deserves
Key Takeaways
- → Identity is not continuous consciousness but something more fragmented and reconstructed — the self is more fragile than our experience of it suggests
- → Loyalty can be felt without being rationally justified — and the gap between the feeling and the justification is where Scalzi's most interesting scenes live
- → Military culture's suppression of individual identity is both necessary for unit cohesion and deeply corrosive to the humans within it
| Author | John Scalzi |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Tor Books |
| Pages | 344 |
| Published | February 27, 2006 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Science Fiction, Military Science Fiction, Space Opera |
The Ghost Brigades Review
The Ghost Brigades is the second novel in John Scalzi’s Old Man’s War universe, and in some ways it is a more philosophically interesting book than its predecessor. Where Old Man’s War was a fairly straightforward military SF adventure with a clever central conceit, The Ghost Brigades takes one of the elements introduced in that book — the Special Forces soldiers created from the DNA of the dead, who exist without any memory of their previous lives — and uses it to ask genuine questions about identity, consciousness, and what it means to be a person.
The novel’s protagonist is Jared Dirac, a Ghost Brigades soldier into whom the consciousness of a traitor named Charles Boutin has been inserted — unsuccessfully, as far as the CDF can tell. But as Jared serves in the field, fragments of Boutin’s memories and personality begin to surface, raising the question that structures the novel: Is Jared Dirac a new person? A copy of Boutin? Neither? And what does the answer mean for what he owes to the CDF and what he might owe to Boutin’s cause?
Scalzi handles these questions with more philosophical care than his light, entertaining prose style might suggest. He is not a novelist who asks readers to do heavy lifting, but he has thought seriously about the implications of his premise, and the best sections of The Ghost Brigades take identity apart in genuinely useful ways. The military action sequences are as well-executed as in the first book; the philosophical dividend is considerably larger.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "The Ghost Brigades" about?
The Special Forces soldiers of the Colonial Defense Forces are the Ghost Brigades — created from the DNA of the dead, with no memories of previous lives. When a traitor's consciousness is inserted into one of them, Scalzi explores identity and loyalty in a worthy sequel to Old Man's War.
What are the key takeaways from "The Ghost Brigades"?
Identity is not continuous consciousness but something more fragmented and reconstructed — the self is more fragile than our experience of it suggests Loyalty can be felt without being rationally justified — and the gap between the feeling and the justification is where Scalzi's most interesting scenes live Military culture's suppression of individual identity is both necessary for unit cohesion and deeply corrosive to the humans within it
Is "The Ghost Brigades" worth reading?
A more philosophically interesting book than Old Man's War — Scalzi uses the Ghost Brigades concept to ask genuine questions about identity and what it means to be a person, while delivering everything fans of the first book want.
Ready to Read The Ghost Brigades?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: