Editors Reads Verdict
Stronger than its predecessor in every respect: the emotional stakes are higher because the characters have been built through an entire book, and the ending has the kind of devastating, inevitable quality that marks Schwab's best work.
What We Loved
- Stronger than its predecessor in every measurable way — the emotional stakes land because the characters were built first
- The Chaos Eater is a genuinely inventive antagonist that externalises both protagonists' internal conflicts
- The ending is devastating and earned — Schwab does not blink or soften what the story demands
- August's arc — deliberate suppression of humanity for the sake of necessity — is handled with real complexity
Minor Drawbacks
- Readers who did not connect with This Savage Song's concept-heavy world will not be converted here
- The Kate-in-Prosperity sections move slower than the parallel Verity storyline
- At 512 pages, some middle sections feel longer than the duology's tight premise requires
Key Takeaways
- → Hardening yourself to function in a difficult world is not clearly strength or loss — it may be both simultaneously
- → A sequel earns its existence by refusing to repeat the original's story while deepening its themes
- → The most honest endings cost something real — conclusions that spare the characters betray the story's premises
- → What we suppress in order to become what circumstances require us to be is worth grieving
| Author | V.E. Schwab |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Greenwillow Books |
| Pages | 512 |
| Published | June 13, 2017 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Fantasy, Young Adult, Dark Fantasy, Urban Fantasy |
Our Dark Duet Review
Sequels to concept-driven first novels face a particular challenge: the ideas that made the original feel fresh are now known quantities, and the follow-up must find something new to say with them. Our Dark Duet solves this problem by refusing to repeat itself. Where This Savage Song was about two people performing identities they did not quite believe in, its sequel is about what happens when the performance starts to become real — and whether that is salvation or catastrophe.
Six months on, August and Kate are separated and changed. Kate is in Prosperity, training to fight monsters, trying to become what her father always wanted her to be. August has taken on a role of authority in Verity that requires a coldness he has been deliberately cultivating, suppressing the parts of himself that want to be human because those parts are incompatible with what the situation requires. Both of them are becoming harder versions of themselves. The novel asks whether that hardening is strength or loss.
The new threat — a monster called the Chaos Eater that spreads violence like a contagion — is more conceptually interesting than the antagonists in the first book, because it externalises what both August and Kate are fighting internally. Schwab uses it to drive a plot that keeps both protagonists moving while ratcheting up the emotional stakes.
The ending is the novel’s greatest achievement. Schwab does not blink or soften the implications of the story she has told. The conclusion is earned, devastating in the way that conclusions to character-driven duologies can be when the author has been honest throughout about what the story was actually about. Our Dark Duet is the rarer thing: a finale better than its opening.
Reading Guides
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "Our Dark Duet" about?
Six months after This Savage Song, Kate and August are in different cities, changed by what they survived. A new kind of monster — one that neither side of Verity created — emerges, and the only way to face it requires both of them to confront what they're becoming. The Monsters of Verity duology concludes.
What are the key takeaways from "Our Dark Duet"?
Hardening yourself to function in a difficult world is not clearly strength or loss — it may be both simultaneously A sequel earns its existence by refusing to repeat the original's story while deepening its themes The most honest endings cost something real — conclusions that spare the characters betray the story's premises What we suppress in order to become what circumstances require us to be is worth grieving
Is "Our Dark Duet" worth reading?
Stronger than its predecessor in every respect: the emotional stakes are higher because the characters have been built through an entire book, and the ending has the kind of devastating, inevitable quality that marks Schwab's best work.
Ready to Read Our Dark Duet?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: