Editors Reads Verdict
A suppressed masterwork of gothic intensity — Mathilda transforms personal grief and trauma into a tightly controlled novella that feels shockingly contemporary in its psychological honesty about loss, guilt, and the impossibility of recovery.
What We Loved
- The psychological intensity is remarkable — Shelley renders states of grief and guilt with a precision that anticipates twentieth-century confession writing
- The novella form is perfectly suited to the material: it is exactly as long as it needs to be
- The biographical context — Shelley's relationship with her own father William Godwin — adds layers that deepen without overwhelming the text
Minor Drawbacks
- The relentlessly dark emotional register can be exhausting; there is no relief or counterweight within the novella itself
- The gothic framing occasionally stylises emotions that might have more power rendered more plainly
Key Takeaways
- → Shelley was processing her grief at the death of her infant son and the damage in her relationship with her father through the most oblique and yet most direct means available to her
- → The novella's suppression for 140 years is itself a significant literary-historical event — Godwin refused to return the manuscript
- → Mathilda belongs to a tradition of female gothic that Shelley helped define, in which the domestic space is the source of horror
| Author | Mary Shelley |
|---|---|
| Publisher | University of North Carolina Press |
| Pages | 96 |
| Published | January 1, 1959 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Gothic Fiction, Classic Fiction, Literary Fiction |
Mathilda Review
Mathilda has one of the most extraordinary publication histories in English literature. Mary Shelley wrote it in 1819, in the aftermath of the death of her infant son William and in a period of severe marital and personal crisis. She sent the manuscript to her father, William Godwin — the philosopher and radical, one of the most eminent intellectuals of his age — for his opinion. He was appalled. He refused to return the manuscript. It remained suppressed until 1959, when it was finally published, 140 years after its composition.
The subject matter explains Godwin’s response. Mathilda is a short novel — really a novella, barely ninety pages — about a young woman whose father falls incestuously in love with her, confesses his passion, and then kills himself in shame. Mathilda survives but does not recover. She retreats from the world, lives in isolation on a moor, and narrates her history in a letter to a poet friend who has tried and failed to draw her back to life.
The autobiographical resonances are not difficult to trace: Shelley’s relationship with her own father was complicated, her grief after her son’s death was crushing, and the emotional texture of the novella — the guilt, the contamination, the sense that something has been destroyed that can never be restored — maps closely onto her documented psychological state. But Mathilda is not merely autobiographical transcription. It is shaped, controlled, and formally precise.
What is most striking about the novella, read now, is how contemporary it feels. The psychological mechanisms Shelley describes — the way trauma forecloses certain futures, the impossibility of explaining the specifics of one’s damage to those who have not experienced it, the exhaustion of surviving something that should not have been survived — are described with an accuracy that anticipates the language of therapeutic psychology by more than a century.
Our rating: 3.9/5
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "Mathilda" about?
Written in 1819 but suppressed by Shelley's father and unpublished until 1959, Mathilda is a harrowing gothic novella about a young woman destroyed by her father's incestuous obsession and her subsequent withdrawal into grief. Autobiographical in its emotional truth, it is among the most painfully honest works Shelley ever wrote.
What are the key takeaways from "Mathilda"?
Shelley was processing her grief at the death of her infant son and the damage in her relationship with her father through the most oblique and yet most direct means available to her The novella's suppression for 140 years is itself a significant literary-historical event — Godwin refused to return the manuscript Mathilda belongs to a tradition of female gothic that Shelley helped define, in which the domestic space is the source of horror
Is "Mathilda" worth reading?
A suppressed masterwork of gothic intensity — Mathilda transforms personal grief and trauma into a tightly controlled novella that feels shockingly contemporary in its psychological honesty about loss, guilt, and the impossibility of recovery.
Ready to Read Mathilda?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: