Beautiful Ruins

The Cliff at Porto Vergogna

The novel opens in 1962 on a fictional sliver of the Ligurian coast — a village so vertical and so remote that it barely qualifies as a destination. Pasquale Tursi, a young innkeeper who has inherited a single crumbling hotel from his father, is trying to build a beach where there is no beach, terracing the cliff with a futile optimism that Walter presents as entirely serious and entirely absurd at once. Into this scene arrives Dee Moray, a young American actress who has been quietly dispatched from the set of Cleopatra in Rome with what she has been told is a terminal illness.

The courtship that develops between Pasquale and Dee across the following days is the emotional anchor of the entire novel. Walter renders it with careful restraint — there is no consummation, no grand declaration, only two people paying close attention to each other across a language barrier, on a cliff above the Ligurian Sea, for a few days in April. The brevity is the point. Walter is interested in how much weight a short encounter can carry across a life, and these opening chapters establish that weight with a delicacy that the rest of the novel earns the right to unpack.

Fifty Years Later, and the Shape of What Was Lost

Beautiful Ruins does not stay in 1962. The novel moves between that Italian spring and a half-dozen other times and places: a present-day Hollywood production company where a faded producer is running out of road, a young development assistant trying to figure out what she believes in, the Cleopatra set where Richard Burton and Elizabeth Taylor’s affair is consuming everything around it, and a series of later moments in Pasquale’s life as he ages toward a reckoning with what the encounter with Dee actually meant.

The time-jumping structure requires patience — the early chapters introduce threads that seem unrelated — but Walter’s architecture is deliberate. Each strand illuminates the others in retrospect, and the novel’s emotional logic depends on the reader holding several versions of the same story in mind simultaneously. The Hollywood present-day material, with its sharp comedy about the machinery of development and the people it grinds up, provides an ironic counterweight to the lyrical Italian past. The contrast is not cynical; it is honest about the distance between what we imagine and what we make.

Dreams and the Cost of Keeping Them

The thematic center of Beautiful Ruins is the question of what people sacrifice to pursue their dreams — and what happens when the sacrifice turns out to have been for nothing. Almost every character in the novel has organized their life around an ambition that has either been corrupted, deferred, or quietly surrendered. Pasquale wanted to build something. Dee wanted to act. The producer wanted to make films that mattered. A peripheral character, a failed novelist, appears in an extended excerpt of his own disastrous fiction, which Walter includes in full: a piece of writing that is both genuinely bad and genuinely earnest, and which is one of the funniest and most sympathetic things in the book.

Walter does not moralize about any of this. The novel does not argue that the dreams were wrong, or that the characters should have wanted different things, or that the pursuit itself was the real reward. It simply follows the people who chased something and traces what remains. The tone that results — warm, comic, melancholy, honest — is the novel’s primary achievement and the quality that has made it so persistently beloved.

A Novel That Plays With Its Own Form

One of the more unusual pleasures of Beautiful Ruins is its structural self-awareness. The novel includes a full excerpt from the failed novelist’s manuscript (intentionally terrible in an instructive way), a chapter written as a screenplay, and passages that read as reported history of the Cleopatra production. These formal departures are not experiments for their own sake; each mode of telling illuminates something the surrounding narrative cannot reach directly.

The screenplay chapter in particular demonstrates how the grammar of film — cuts, close-ups, the hard logic of scene and sequence — flattens and distorts the same events that prose can hold in suspension. Walter is making an argument about what fiction can do that other forms cannot, and he makes it by example rather than assertion. For a novel set so deeply in the world of Hollywood, there is something quietly pointed about how much more the prose sections contain than the cinematic one.

Our rating: 4/5 — A generous, structurally inventive novel that finds genuine beauty in failed dreams, brief encounters, and the long distances between who we were and who we became.

Reading Guides

• Books Like Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow: 11 Novels About Creativity, Friendship, and Making Something That Lasts