Editors Reads Verdict
Hosseini's most formally ambitious work — the kaleidoscopic structure takes some getting used to, but the accumulated emotional weight is considerable, and the portrait of Afghanistan across six decades is moving and complex.
What We Loved
- The multigenerational structure allows Hosseini to trace the long consequences of single decisions across decades
- The Afghan historical backdrop — from pre-Soviet times through diaspora — is handled with more complexity than in his earlier books
- The interleaved voices create a genuine polyphonic effect
Minor Drawbacks
- Some of the narrative threads are more compelling than others, creating uneven engagement
- The kaleidoscopic structure can feel fragmentary in the middle sections before it coheres
Key Takeaways
- → The consequences of family decisions ripple outward through generations in ways the original actors cannot foresee
- → Diaspora creates its own complicated relationship to an origin country that continues to change while the émigré's idea of it fossilizes
- → Sacrifice motivated by love does not make the sacrifice less painful for those who experience it
| Author | Khaled Hosseini |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Riverhead Books |
| Pages | 404 |
| Published | May 21, 2013 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Literary Fiction, Historical Fiction |
And the Mountains Echoed Review
And the Mountains Echoed is Khaled Hosseini’s third novel and his most structurally ambitious, a departure from the relatively straightforward dual-narrative of The Kite Runner and A Thousand Splendid Suns into something more kaleidoscopic and fragmented. The novel opens in 1952 with a poor Afghani father telling his young children a parable about a father’s choice, then follows with the act that the parable was preparing: he will give his daughter Pari to a wealthy Kabul family who can offer her a better life than he can. From that single act of sacrifice and separation, the novel traces outward through six decades and half a dozen countries.
The structure is Hosseini’s risk and his achievement. Each chapter is narrated by a different character — Pari’s brother Abdullah, who cannot stop missing her; the French-Afghan woman who adopts Pari; a Greek plastic surgeon who volunteers in Afghanistan; a niece in Kabul making difficult choices; characters in Paris, California, Greece — and the connections between them are sometimes direct and sometimes oblique. In the novel’s weakest sections, the kaleidoscope fragments too widely and the emotional connection to the opening becomes difficult to sustain. In its strongest — particularly the Abdullah thread and the eventual reckoning between siblings across their different lives — the accumulated weight is considerable.
What Hosseini adds in this novel that his earlier books didn’t fully explore is complexity about Afghanistan itself. The country here is not simply a backdrop for tragedy but a place with a specific, changing history — the period before Soviet invasion, the post-Soviet chaos, the Taliban years, the post-2001 period — and the characters who left and those who stayed have developed genuinely different relationships to what Afghanistan is and means. The diaspora theme is handled with more nuance than sentimentality.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "And the Mountains Echoed" about?
A multigenerational story spanning 60 years and several continents, beginning with a poor Afghan family's decision to give away a daughter and rippling outward through the lives of those touched by that act of sacrifice. Hosseini's most structurally ambitious novel.
What are the key takeaways from "And the Mountains Echoed"?
The consequences of family decisions ripple outward through generations in ways the original actors cannot foresee Diaspora creates its own complicated relationship to an origin country that continues to change while the émigré's idea of it fossilizes Sacrifice motivated by love does not make the sacrifice less painful for those who experience it
Is "And the Mountains Echoed" worth reading?
Hosseini's most formally ambitious work — the kaleidoscopic structure takes some getting used to, but the accumulated emotional weight is considerable, and the portrait of Afghanistan across six decades is moving and complex.
Ready to Read And the Mountains Echoed?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: