Editors Reads Verdict
The second Shades of Magic novel delivers on the world's promise. The Essen Tasch is a showcase for Schwab's plotting instincts — competitive, politically layered, and full of the kind of reversals that make fantasy tournaments compelling. Lila remains the series' finest creation.
What We Loved
- The Essen Tasch tournament works on multiple levels simultaneously — political tension, magical spectacle, and character pressure cooker
- Lila Bard remains the most dynamic presence in the series — morally complicated, competent, and impossible to predict
- The world's politics, sketched in the first book, become fully operational here with genuine stakes
- Ending recontextualises the entire trilogy's stakes and propels directly into the conclusion
Minor Drawbacks
- Explicitly a middle volume — the central crisis is opened and not resolved, making this unsatisfying as a standalone
- The tournament structure, while well-executed, can feel like a deliberate delay of the larger confrontation
- Kell's chapters are less compelling than Lila's, creating an imbalance in POV quality
Key Takeaways
- → Competence paired with moral ambiguity is more interesting than heroism paired with moral clarity
- → Tournaments and competitions make effective narrative devices because they combine spectacle with political consequence
- → Four months of distance between events can change characters more fundamentally than any single crisis
- → The middle volume of a trilogy exists to deepen what was established — and to set fires the finale must put out
| Author | V.E. Schwab |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Tor Books |
| Pages | 512 |
| Published | February 23, 2016 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Fantasy, Adventure, Fiction |
A Gathering of Shadows Review
A Gathering of Shadows picks up four months after A Darker Shade of Magic closed, and Schwab uses the gap well. Kell is chafing under the restrictions imposed by King Maxim; Lila is somewhere on the seas, discovering the full extent of her magical abilities while operating under an assumed identity. Their reunion — and the circumstances that occasion it — is one of the book’s pleasures.
The Essen Tasch, the inter-London magical tournament, provides the book’s structural backbone. As a narrative device, it serves multiple functions: it creates a pressure cooker for political tension between the three Londons; it allows Schwab to showcase magical combat in an extended, escalating format; and it gives Lila a plausible reason to use her abilities in public while maintaining her cover. The tournament format is well-executed, with enough unexpected reversals to stay interesting.
What works: Lila continues to be the series’ most dynamic presence — competent, morally complicated, and completely committed to her own survival in ways that constantly bump against the reader’s desire for her to be more conventionally heroic. The world’s politics, sketched in the first book, become fully operational here. The ending recontextualises the stakes dramatically.
The final pages: A Gathering of Shadows ends on a cliffhanger that propels readers directly into A Conjuring of Light. Schwab does not resolve the central crisis she opens — this is explicitly the middle volume.
Verdict: A stronger second act than many trilogies manage. Read immediately before A Conjuring of Light.
Reading Guides
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "A Gathering of Shadows" about?
Four months after the events of the first book, Kell is trapped in Red London, confined by King Maxim after the near-catastrophe of the black stone. Lila Bard is somewhere on the seas, pursuing her own ambitions. When the Essen Tasch — a magical tournament held every four years — draws competitors from all three Londons, their paths converge again.
What are the key takeaways from "A Gathering of Shadows"?
Competence paired with moral ambiguity is more interesting than heroism paired with moral clarity Tournaments and competitions make effective narrative devices because they combine spectacle with political consequence Four months of distance between events can change characters more fundamentally than any single crisis The middle volume of a trilogy exists to deepen what was established — and to set fires the finale must put out
Is "A Gathering of Shadows" worth reading?
The second Shades of Magic novel delivers on the world's promise. The Essen Tasch is a showcase for Schwab's plotting instincts — competitive, politically layered, and full of the kind of reversals that make fantasy tournaments compelling. Lila remains the series' finest creation.
Ready to Read A Gathering of Shadows?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: