Editors Reads Verdict
The book that made Melville famous is a hybrid of memoir, adventure fiction, and cultural criticism that anticipates the critique of colonialism and 'civilisation' by a century — and whose dismissal by reviewers as too well-written to be true tells us more about nineteenth-century class assumptions than about the book.
What We Loved
- Melville's critique of Western civilisation's moral claims against 'savage' peoples is more sophisticated than almost any contemporary equivalent
- The Marquesas setting is rendered with sensory richness and genuine ethnographic attention
- The adventure narrative is propulsive and the Fayaway episodes have a lyrical quality that anticipates Melville's later prose
Minor Drawbacks
- The book exists in an uncomfortable middle ground between fiction and memoir — Melville embellished his actual experience significantly
- The anxiety about cannibalism that runs through the narrator's time with the Typee is both the book's structural tension and its least examined prejudice
- Some of the ethnographic descriptions are lengthy by current reading standards
Key Takeaways
- → The 'savage' and the 'civilised' are relative terms defined by power, and the Marquesas islanders Melville describes are in many respects more humane than the Western ships that visit them
- → The missionaries and whalers arrive bearing Christianity and commerce, which Melville presents as joint instruments of destruction
- → The anxiety about leaving — the narrator's desire to escape the valley despite the Typee's hospitality — is the book's unresolved psychological centre
- → American reviewers' scepticism that a sailor could have written so well reveals the class assumptions embedded in literary credibility
| Author | Herman Melville |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Penguin Classics |
| Pages | 336 |
| Published | January 1, 1846 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Classic Fiction, American Literature, Adventure Fiction |
Typee Review
Herman Melville was twenty-six years old when Typee was published in 1846 by John Murray in London and Wiley & Putnam in New York, and its reception was the most successful of his career: the public loved it, the reviews were mostly warm, and the debate about whether it was true was conducted at a volume that only helped sales. Several reviewers suggested that the book was too well-written to have been produced by a working sailor. This argument — which amounts to saying that a man without formal education cannot write well — says everything about the reviewers and nothing about the book, and Melville would spend the rest of his career trying to recover an audience that had decided it liked his adventures but not his ambitions.
The novel is based on Melville’s actual time among the Typee people of Nuku Hiva in the Marquesas Islands in 1842, after he and a companion jumped ship from a whaling vessel. He spent approximately a month in the Typee valley — he claimed, in the novel, that it was four months, a significant embellishment — before escaping on an Australian whaler. What he did with the experience was more interesting than a simple adventure narrative: he produced a work that used the Marquesas as a vantage point from which to critique Western civilisation’s self-congratulation about its own superiority.
The narrator Tommo — Melville’s fictional self — is received by the Typee with hospitality that is indistinguishable from generosity. They feed him, care for his infected leg, provide female companionship in the person of Fayaway, and ask very little in return except that he remain. The cannibal accusation that shadows the narrator’s stay is the book’s anxiety rather than its conclusion: there is evidence, ambiguous, that the Typee practice ritual cannibalism of enemies killed in warfare. Melville treats this with far more sophistication than his contemporaries: compared to the behaviour of the European and American ships visiting the islands — the whalers who kidnap and abuse islanders, the missionaries who systematically destroy the culture — the Typee’s alleged cannibalism occupies an interesting moral position.
The narrator’s eventual escape, despite the hospitality he has received, is rendered without triumphalism. He has been comfortable, cared for, even happy. He leaves because he cannot not leave: the anxiety about cannibalism, the pull of his own culture, the specific American restlessness that will later drive Ishmael to sea, refuses to be stilled. The book ends not with a critique of his own society or a celebration of the Marquesas but with a young man swimming toward a ship, and the ambivalence is complete.
Our rating: 4.0/5 — The book that made Melville famous and that already contains, in embryo, the cultural critique that would reach its fullest expression in Moby-Dick.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "Typee" about?
Melville's first novel, based on his actual time among the Typee people of the Marquesas Islands after jumping ship, is part adventure narrative, part ethnography, and part critique of Western civilization's assumptions about 'savagery.'
What are the key takeaways from "Typee"?
The 'savage' and the 'civilised' are relative terms defined by power, and the Marquesas islanders Melville describes are in many respects more humane than the Western ships that visit them The missionaries and whalers arrive bearing Christianity and commerce, which Melville presents as joint instruments of destruction The anxiety about leaving — the narrator's desire to escape the valley despite the Typee's hospitality — is the book's unresolved psychological centre American reviewers' scepticism that a sailor could have written so well reveals the class assumptions embedded in literary credibility
Is "Typee" worth reading?
The book that made Melville famous is a hybrid of memoir, adventure fiction, and cultural criticism that anticipates the critique of colonialism and 'civilisation' by a century — and whose dismissal by reviewers as too well-written to be true tells us more about nineteenth-century class assumptions than about the book.
Ready to Read Typee?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: