Editors Reads Verdict
Many readers consider The Scar better than Perdido Street Station — Armada is one of the great fantastical cities in contemporary fiction, and Bellis is a more interesting protagonist than Isaac Dan der Grimnebulin.
What We Loved
- Armada — a city built on lashed-together ships — is one of the great fantastical settings in contemporary fiction
- Bellis Coldwine is a more morally complex and less straightforwardly sympathetic protagonist than Isaac
- The central mystery of the Scar and what the Armada leaders want with it is genuinely compelling
Minor Drawbacks
- At 638 pages the density is formidable — Miéville never simplifies
- Some subplots require more patience than others
Key Takeaways
- → A city built on ships is a city defined by movement and capture — its culture reflects this in every institution
- → The most interesting political questions concern communities that are not states — how do they organise, what do they owe their members
- → What you know and what you were told are not always the same thing — Bellis discovers this several times
| Author | China Miéville |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Del Rey |
| Pages | 638 |
| Published | August 27, 2002 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Fantasy, Science Fiction |
| Difficulty | Advanced |
| Best For | Readers of Perdido Street Station ready for the second Bas-Lag novel, or anyone who wants Miéville at his most imaginative world-building. |
Armada
The Scar begins in New Crobuzon — the city of Perdido Street Station — but moves quickly onto the open sea. Bellis Coldwine, a linguist, is fleeing the city after the events of the previous novel on a ship bound for a distant colony. The ship is captured by Armada’s fleet and taken to Armada itself: a floating city built from hundreds of lashed-together ships, spanning miles of ocean, governed by a committee of powerful individuals including the Lovers — a couple who carve matching scars on each other’s faces.
Armada is preparing for an enormous and mysterious undertaking. Bellis is determined to escape. Both objectives require navigating a community completely different from any city she has known.
Armada as Subject
Miéville’s cities are always arguments about how societies organise themselves. Armada’s statelessness — it is not a nation, it acknowledges no territory, it is composed of captured and absorbed ships from every maritime culture — produces a specific kind of politics: genuinely pluralist but governed by the agenda of those powerful enough to direct it. Its internal conflicts mirror those of any revolutionary commune that has achieved power without fully deciding what to do with it.
The central mystery — what is the Scar, and what does the Armada leadership intend to do at it — is handled with the slow, dense revelation that characterises Miéville’s best work.
Our rating: 4.4/5 — Arguably better than Perdido Street Station: a more complex protagonist, a more interesting setting, and a mystery that fully rewards the investment required.
Reading Guides
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "The Scar" about?
Set in the same world as Perdido Street Station — Bellis Coldwine flees New Crobuzon on a ship that is captured by pirates and brought to Armada, a city built on a raft of lashed-together ships on the open sea.
Who should read "The Scar"?
Readers of Perdido Street Station ready for the second Bas-Lag novel, or anyone who wants Miéville at his most imaginative world-building.
What are the key takeaways from "The Scar"?
A city built on ships is a city defined by movement and capture — its culture reflects this in every institution The most interesting political questions concern communities that are not states — how do they organise, what do they owe their members What you know and what you were told are not always the same thing — Bellis discovers this several times
Is "The Scar" worth reading?
Many readers consider The Scar better than Perdido Street Station — Armada is one of the great fantastical cities in contemporary fiction, and Bellis is a more interesting protagonist than Isaac Dan der Grimnebulin.
Ready to Read The Scar?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: