Editors Reads Verdict
The best of the trilogy — Julia's backstory is the emotional core and one of the darkest, most powerful things Grossman has written, while Quentin's arc gives the reader's disillusionment somewhere productive to go.
What We Loved
- Julia's backstory — learning magic in the underground, at enormous personal cost — is more emotionally powerful than anything in The Magicians
- The structure, alternating between Quentin's quest and Julia's past, is the most formally accomplished of the trilogy
- Grossman earns the emotional weight of the ending by following his characters' unhappiness to its logical conclusion
Minor Drawbacks
- Julia's storyline contains content (sexual violence) that some readers find difficult, though Grossman handles it with care
- Readers who haven't read The Magicians will lack the context that makes the Fillory setting emotionally resonant
Key Takeaways
- → The hunger for magic — for meaning, for a world more real than the mundane — is both understandable and dangerous
- → Those excluded from official pathways to power find unofficial ones, at far greater cost, and what they find is not always what they sought
- → Sacrifice is more meaningful when it is chosen without certainty of reward
| Author | Lev Grossman |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Penguin Books |
| Pages | 400 |
| Published | August 9, 2011 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Fantasy, Literary Fiction |
The Magician King Review
The Magician King is the second volume of Lev Grossman’s Magicians trilogy, and it is widely considered the finest of the three — the one in which Grossman finds the emotional depths that The Magicians only gestured toward. It follows Quentin Coldwater, now a king of Fillory, the fantasy world he always dreamed of reaching, as restlessness and a desire for meaning drive him on a quest that eventually strips away everything he has gained. Alongside Quentin’s story runs Julia’s — told in extended flashback — which reveals how she learned magic outside the official Brakebills system and at what cost.
Julia’s storyline is the novel’s heart and its most significant achievement. The Magicians showed us only the polished Brakebills pathway to magical education — the examination, the curriculum, the faculty. Julia, who was denied entry to Brakebills despite her genuine ability, found her own way through the underground network of hedge witches and self-taught magicians who exist outside the official structure. What she found there, and what it cost her, constitutes the darkest and most emotionally powerful section of the trilogy. Grossman handles it with gravity and without sensationalism.
The parallel structure — Quentin’s present quest and Julia’s past — works beautifully, each storyline commenting on the other and both converging on the novel’s climax, which imposes genuine costs and genuine changes. The Magician King is the book in which Grossman fully earns the literary ambition he announced in The Magicians: the sense that fantasy can carry the weight of real emotional experience without simplifying it.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "The Magician King" about?
Quentin Coldwater is now a king of Fillory, but restlessness drives him on a quest that leads back to Earth — while Julia's parallel story reveals how she gained her devastating magical power outside the Brakebills system. The most emotionally sophisticated volume in the Magicians trilogy.
What are the key takeaways from "The Magician King"?
The hunger for magic — for meaning, for a world more real than the mundane — is both understandable and dangerous Those excluded from official pathways to power find unofficial ones, at far greater cost, and what they find is not always what they sought Sacrifice is more meaningful when it is chosen without certainty of reward
Is "The Magician King" worth reading?
The best of the trilogy — Julia's backstory is the emotional core and one of the darkest, most powerful things Grossman has written, while Quentin's arc gives the reader's disillusionment somewhere productive to go.
Ready to Read The Magician King?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: