Editors Reads Verdict
The most formally perfect comedy in the English language — a machine of wit so precisely engineered that every scene, every entrance, every revelation springs the same trap in a different direction. The epigrams would be enough; the plot architecture is a separate achievement.
What We Loved
- The epigrams are without equal in the language — quotable, paradoxical, and structurally load-bearing rather than merely decorative
- The double-plot architecture is a comic engineering masterpiece — every complication creates and solves three others simultaneously
- Lady Bracknell is the greatest comic supporting character in English drama
- The play's critique of Victorian sincerity is buried so deep in the laughter that it arrives before you notice it
Minor Drawbacks
- The plot's resolution — the foundling revealed — is deliberately farcical and some readers want more psychological depth
- Stage directions and setting descriptions require contextual knowledge of the period to fully appreciate
Key Takeaways
- → Earnestness — the Victorian ideal of sincere, principled conduct — is itself a kind of performance, subject to the same scrutiny as any fiction
- → Identity is not innate but constructed and named: the play turns on a name, not a character
- → Social forms — engagements, proposals, family names, handbags — are revealed as arbitrary conventions with absolute power
- → The trivial and the serious exchange places throughout: small things are treated gravely and grave things are dismissed as trivial, and this inversion is the play's comic engine
| Author | Oscar Wilde |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Dover |
| Pages | 96 |
| Published | February 14, 1895 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Classic Drama, British Literature, Comedy |
The Funniest Play in the English Language
The Importance of Being Earnest opened at the St. James’s Theatre in London on 14 February 1895, to the best notices Wilde had ever received. Three months later he was arrested. The play ran for eighty-three performances, was taken off when he went to prison, and has been in continuous production ever since. It is the only work in the language that has never stopped being staged.
The premise involves two young men who have invented fictional identities to escape social obligations. John Worthing — known to his country neighbours as a respectable guardian, known in London as the disreputable Ernest — has fabricated a dissolute brother whose scrapes require periodic rescuing in town. Algernon Moncrieff has invented a chronic invalid named Bunbury whose illness requires regular visits to the country whenever Algy wishes to avoid an obligation in London. Both fictions collapse simultaneously when the two men meet at Algy’s flat and discover that each has been lying in the same direction.
The Machine of Wit
Wilde himself called it “a trivial comedy for serious people,” and the description is precisely accurate. The play’s surface is froth — misplaced handbags, cucumber sandwiches, mistaken names, doubled proposals. The machinery underneath is a precision instrument for dismantling Victorian moral earnestness from within.
The epigrams come so frequently that they threaten to overwhelm the play’s architecture, and yet they don’t, because Wilde engineers each one to do double work: they are simultaneously funny, accurate about their stated targets, and quietly subversive of the speaker. When Lady Bracknell observes that she does not approve of mercenary marriages and that a man should know either everything or nothing, she is not being hypocritical — she is simply inhabiting the class codes of her world so completely that their contradictions are invisible to her. The comedy lives in that gap between self-image and reality.
Lady Bracknell and the Handbag
Lady Bracknell’s interrogation of Jack Worthing — checking his suitability as a prospective son-in-law — is one of the great scenes in English comedy. Her reaction to the news that Jack was discovered as a baby in a handbag left in the cloakroom at Victoria Station — “A handbag?” — is probably the single most famous line in the play and can be delivered only one way, the way Wilde has written it: with the full weight of outraged social convention brought to bear on an object whose ordinariness makes the outrage funnier.
The handbag, it turns out, is the key to Jack’s identity: he was, in fact, born Ernest, and is in fact Algy’s brother, and has been unknowingly telling the truth about his name all along. The resolution is a farce resolution — perfectly calibrated to be simultaneously satisfying and absurd — and Wilde’s final line, Jack’s declaration that he has now realized “the vital Importance of Being Earnest,” closes the play on a pun that crystallizes everything. The entire comedy is contained in that final word.
Our rating: 4.8/5 — The most brilliant comedy in the English language: effortless on the surface, flawlessly engineered underneath, and somehow getting funnier every decade.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "The Importance of Being Earnest" about?
Two young men have invented fictional alter egos to escape social obligations — Jack Worthing has invented 'Ernest' in town, and Algernon Moncrieff has invented a sickly friend 'Bunbury' in the country. Wilde's masterpiece of comic drama is the funniest play in the English language, a vehicle for some of the most memorable epigrams ever written, and beneath the surface glitter a perfectly constructed satire of Victorian earnestness, sincerity, and the institution of marriage.
What are the key takeaways from "The Importance of Being Earnest"?
Earnestness — the Victorian ideal of sincere, principled conduct — is itself a kind of performance, subject to the same scrutiny as any fiction Identity is not innate but constructed and named: the play turns on a name, not a character Social forms — engagements, proposals, family names, handbags — are revealed as arbitrary conventions with absolute power The trivial and the serious exchange places throughout: small things are treated gravely and grave things are dismissed as trivial, and this inversion is the play's comic engine
Is "The Importance of Being Earnest" worth reading?
The most formally perfect comedy in the English language — a machine of wit so precisely engineered that every scene, every entrance, every revelation springs the same trap in a different direction. The epigrams would be enough; the plot architecture is a separate achievement.
Ready to Read The Importance of Being Earnest?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: