Editors Reads Verdict
Jimenez's warmest novel: the dog-adoption premise is charming without being cloying, the grief thread is handled with sensitivity, and the music subplot gives the romance a texture that most in the genre don't bother with. The found-dog as matchmaker has never been more successfully deployed.
What We Loved
- Tucker the dog is a genuinely effective plot device and a charming presence throughout
- The grief arc is handled with real sensitivity — Sloane's unreadiness is never treated as a character flaw
- Jason's musician life gives the long-distance element of the romance a specific texture
- Jimenez's warmth for her characters is at its most evident here
Minor Drawbacks
- The logistics of the long-distance situation strain credibility at points
- Some secondary characters are given more page time than their development justifies
- The pacing in the middle section occasionally loses the momentum built in the opening
Key Takeaways
- → Grief has its own timeline that cannot be negotiated with or overridden by new happiness
- → A found connection — accidental, unplanned, slightly absurd — can have more staying power than a deliberate one
- → Long-distance relationships require a specific kind of faith that has nothing to do with trust and everything to do with imagination
- → Music creates intimacy between people who haven't met in the same way that letters do
- → Letting go of a person you loved is not a betrayal — it is the final form of love for them
| Author | Abby Jimenez |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Forever |
| Pages | 384 |
| Published | April 14, 2020 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Contemporary Romance, Comedy, Women's Fiction |
| Difficulty | Beginner |
| Best For | Romance readers who want grief handled thoughtfully; dog people; fans of Abby Jimenez's comedic warmth; anyone who has been surprised by connection arriving at the wrong time. |
The Happy Ever After Playlist Review
Abby Jimenez’s second novel is the warmest book in her catalog — a romance built around a premise so charming that it could easily have curdled into cuteness, but Jimenez grounds it in genuine grief and genuine longing. Sloane has not recovered from losing her fiancé Brandon two years before the novel begins. She is not okay in ways she cannot articulate and her friends cannot fix. Then she adopts a dog.
Tucker belongs to Jason, a musician who left him with a neighbor before going on tour. Tucker has escaped the neighbor and found Sloane. Jason contacts her through Tucker’s tag and thus begins one of romance’s more unusual courtships: extended texting between a grieving woman in Los Angeles and a musician on the road, mediated by a dog neither of them planned to be responsible for.
The Grief Thread
What makes the novel more than its charming premise is the specificity of Sloane’s grief. Jimenez does not use Brandon’s death as backstory — it is present throughout, informing Sloane’s hesitations and her self-knowledge and her complicated feelings about being happy. The novel understands that falling for someone new when you are still mourning someone feels like a kind of betrayal, even when it isn’t, and it gives that feeling room without letting it become the obstacle.
Jason
Jason is one of Jimenez’s most appealing heroes: patient, funny, direct about what he wants, and without any of the brooding opacity that romance heroes often deploy to generate conflict. His musician’s life is drawn with enough specificity that the long-distance element of the relationship feels textured rather than convenient.
Our rating: 4.4/5 — Jimenez’s warmest novel, handling grief and new love with a deft balance that its charming dog-adoption premise only partly prepares you for.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "The Happy Ever After Playlist" about?
Two years after losing her fiancé, Sloane is still not okay. Then she accidentally adopts a dog named Tucker — whose owner, Jason, is a musician on tour who keeps showing up in her life. A love story about grief, music, and the way connection can arrive when you've stopped looking for it.
Who should read "The Happy Ever After Playlist"?
Romance readers who want grief handled thoughtfully; dog people; fans of Abby Jimenez's comedic warmth; anyone who has been surprised by connection arriving at the wrong time.
What are the key takeaways from "The Happy Ever After Playlist"?
Grief has its own timeline that cannot be negotiated with or overridden by new happiness A found connection — accidental, unplanned, slightly absurd — can have more staying power than a deliberate one Long-distance relationships require a specific kind of faith that has nothing to do with trust and everything to do with imagination Music creates intimacy between people who haven't met in the same way that letters do Letting go of a person you loved is not a betrayal — it is the final form of love for them
Is "The Happy Ever After Playlist" worth reading?
Jimenez's warmest novel: the dog-adoption premise is charming without being cloying, the grief thread is handled with sensitivity, and the music subplot gives the romance a texture that most in the genre don't bother with. The found-dog as matchmaker has never been more successfully deployed.
Ready to Read The Happy Ever After Playlist?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: