Editors Reads Verdict
Turton deploys the same impossible-situation ingenuity that made The Seven Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle famous, but the ship setting gives The Devil and the Dark Water a sustained claustrophobia and a genuinely historical atmosphere. The supernatural question — is there actually a demon? — is handled with unusual restraint.
What We Loved
- The ship setting is the perfect locked-room container — claustrophobic, historically plausible, and beautifully suited to the genre
- The Pipps-in-the-hold / Hayes-on-deck partnership inverts the expected detective dynamic with genuine ingenuity
- The Dutch Golden Age atmosphere feels researched and lived-in rather than costumed
- Turton holds the supernatural question with impressive discipline until the reframing finale
Minor Drawbacks
- The large cast of suspects can be difficult to track across the extended voyage narrative
- Readers unfamiliar with Turton's approach may find the deliberate misdirection frustrating rather than satisfying
- The novel's length tests patience in the mid-section before the full picture comes into focus
Key Takeaways
- → The best locked-room mysteries use their constraint as a feature rather than a limitation
- → A detective who cannot move must rely entirely on testimony and inference — which reveals as much about the witnesses as the crime
- → Rational explanations and supernatural appearances can coexist in a narrative until the final moment of choice
- → Historical atmosphere is most convincing when the research shapes character motivation rather than merely decoration
- → Everything in a Turton novel is placed precisely — nothing is wasted, and the reframe earns every prior detail
| Author | Stuart Turton |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Sourcebooks Landmark |
| Pages | 464 |
| Published | October 6, 2020 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Mystery, Historical Fiction, Thriller, Gothic Fiction |
The Devil and the Dark Water Review
Stuart Turton’s follow-up to The Seven Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle asks: what happens when you take the locked-room mystery and make the room a ship at sea? The answer is The Devil and the Dark Water, a novel set aboard a seventeenth-century Dutch merchant vessel during the months-long voyage from Batavia to Amsterdam — a container so perfectly suited to the genre’s requirements that it seems surprising no one thought of it first.
The partnership at the centre of the novel — brilliant, imprisoned detective Samuel Pipps and his bodyguard Arent Hayes — inverts the expected dynamic of the genre. Pipps, the mind, is confined to the hold for the novel’s entirety. Hayes, the physical one, conducts the investigation on deck and reports back. The result is a mystery in which the detective must reconstruct events entirely from testimony and evidence brought to him, which gives the investigation an unusual texture: we are always at one remove from the events, filtered through Hayes’s observation and Pipps’s interpretation.
The historical setting is more than atmosphere. Turton has done enough research to give the Dutch Golden Age merchant world a convincing texture — the Company politics, the class hierarchies aboard ship, the particular brutalities of the spice trade — without letting the research slow the plot. The confined world of the Saardam feels lived-in rather than costumed.
The supernatural question is the book’s shrewdest structural choice. A figure calling itself Old Tom is claiming to be a demon, and people are dying in ways that look like demon work. Turton holds the question of whether something genuinely supernatural is occurring with impressive discipline, neither committing to the supernatural nor dismissing it, until the solution is revealed.
The solution is vintage Turton: everything reframes, nothing was wasted.
Our rating: 4.3/5 — A locked-room mystery at sea with a genuine historical atmosphere, an inventive detective partnership, and Turton’s trademark reframing finale.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "The Devil and the Dark Water" about?
1634. A merchant ship departs Batavia for Amsterdam carrying a disgraced detective, his bodyguard, a mysterious prisoner, and a demon that appears to be killing the passengers. Samuel Pipps must solve an impossible mystery from the ship's hold while his bodyguard Arent Hayes investigates on deck above. Turton's locked-room mystery at sea.
What are the key takeaways from "The Devil and the Dark Water"?
The best locked-room mysteries use their constraint as a feature rather than a limitation A detective who cannot move must rely entirely on testimony and inference — which reveals as much about the witnesses as the crime Rational explanations and supernatural appearances can coexist in a narrative until the final moment of choice Historical atmosphere is most convincing when the research shapes character motivation rather than merely decoration Everything in a Turton novel is placed precisely — nothing is wasted, and the reframe earns every prior detail
Is "The Devil and the Dark Water" worth reading?
Turton deploys the same impossible-situation ingenuity that made The Seven Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle famous, but the ship setting gives The Devil and the Dark Water a sustained claustrophobia and a genuinely historical atmosphere. The supernatural question — is there actually a demon? — is handled with unusual restraint.
Ready to Read The Devil and the Dark Water?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: