Editors Reads Verdict
Many readers consider The Crossing McCarthy's finest novel — the wolf section alone is worth the price of admission, and the three journeys accumulate into a meditation on what it means to act in a world that does not care about your intentions.
What We Loved
- The wolf section — the first quarter of the novel — is among the greatest things McCarthy ever wrote
- The cumulative weight of the three journeys produces a devastation that the individual parts do not fully predict
- The encounters with a blind man, a priest, and a tinker's wife contain McCarthy's most direct philosophical statement
Minor Drawbacks
- The middle journey, where Billy searches for his parents' killers, is slower than the outer sections
- The lack of direct connection to All the Pretty Horses until late in the novel may frustrate readers expecting a sequel
Key Takeaways
- → The world does not care about the value of the things you carry across it — only you care, and you will lose them anyway
- → To act in the world is to introduce yourself to loss in a specific and instructive way
- → The stories people tell about their lives are not lies — they are the only way of making sense of what otherwise has no sense
| Author | Cormac McCarthy |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Vintage |
| Pages | 426 |
| Published | June 1, 1994 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Literary Fiction, Western |
| Difficulty | Advanced |
| Best For | Readers of All the Pretty Horses who want to continue the Border Trilogy, and literary fiction readers who want McCarthy's greatest sustained achievement. |
The Wolf
In 1938, Billy Parham is sixteen years old, living on a ranch in New Mexico near the Mexican border. His father has been losing cattle to a wolf, and Billy traps her — a large, pregnant female. Instead of killing her, he decides to return her to Mexico, to the mountains where wolves belong.
The first hundred pages of The Crossing, following Billy’s journey across the border with the wolf on a lead rope, are among the most extraordinary pages in American fiction. The wolf is not a symbol, not a metaphor, not a stand-in for anything. She is a wolf: terrible, beautiful, and entirely herself. Billy’s relationship to her — his obligation toward her, his failure to understand what that obligation means — is the moral engine of the entire novel.
Three Crossings
The novel is structured around three journeys into Mexico, each one costing more than the last. The first, with the wolf, ends in a way Billy could not have predicted. The second, with his brother Boyd, ends in a different kind of loss. The third, alone, carries a weight the novel has been accumulating for three hundred pages.
Between the journeys, strangers tell Billy stories — a blind man, a priest, a tinker’s wife — that are McCarthy’s most direct attempt to articulate what the novel is about: the impossibility of rescuing anything, the obligation to try anyway, and the stories we tell ourselves to make that contradiction liveable.
Our rating: 4.5/5 — McCarthy’s masterpiece: the wolf section alone is worth any price you pay, and the novel only grows darker and more demanding after it.
Reading Guides
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "The Crossing" about?
Billy Parham, sixteen, traps a pregnant wolf in New Mexico and decides to return her to Mexico — three journeys across the border over a decade, each one costing more than the last.
Who should read "The Crossing"?
Readers of All the Pretty Horses who want to continue the Border Trilogy, and literary fiction readers who want McCarthy's greatest sustained achievement.
What are the key takeaways from "The Crossing"?
The world does not care about the value of the things you carry across it — only you care, and you will lose them anyway To act in the world is to introduce yourself to loss in a specific and instructive way The stories people tell about their lives are not lies — they are the only way of making sense of what otherwise has no sense
Is "The Crossing" worth reading?
Many readers consider The Crossing McCarthy's finest novel — the wolf section alone is worth the price of admission, and the three journeys accumulate into a meditation on what it means to act in a world that does not care about your intentions.
Ready to Read The Crossing?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: