Editors Reads Verdict
The Colossus reveals Plath before she became Plath — technically accomplished, formally disciplined, working within inherited traditions while beginning to strain against them. Essential for understanding how Ariel's explosion was prepared, and valuable in its own right for poems of lasting distinction.
What We Loved
- The technical command is evident from the first page — this is a poet who has mastered her craft
- Poems like 'The Colossus,' 'Medallion,' and 'Black Rook in Rainy Weather' stand independently of the later work
- The collection shows a poet in genuine dialogue with the tradition rather than merely imitating it
Minor Drawbacks
- The influence of Yeats and Roethke is sometimes so visible as to feel more imitative than transformative
- Reading backwards from Ariel, the collection can feel like prologue rather than achievement in its own right
Key Takeaways
- → Technical mastery is the foundation on which authentic voice is built — Plath's later freedom required this earlier discipline
- → The father figure that dominates Ariel is already present here, differently handled
- → A first collection reveals a poet's influences in ways the mature work has absorbed and transformed
| Author | Sylvia Plath |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Vintage |
| Pages | 82 |
| Published | January 1, 1960 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Poetry, Confessional Poetry, American Literature |
The Colossus and Other Poems Review
The Colossus and Other Poems was published in the United Kingdom in 1960, when Sylvia Plath was twenty-seven; it appeared in the United States two years later. It is the work of a poet who has spent years in rigorous formal training — at Smith College, on a Fulbright at Cambridge, in years of disciplined practice — and who is in full command of that training while not yet in full command of herself. The voice that produced Ariel is here in preparation, not in arrival.
The title poem addresses the figure of the father as a half-buried colossus whose scale cannot be measured and whose voice, try as the speaker might, cannot be heard clearly or reconstructed. The father — Plath’s own father died when she was eight — will become the central figure of the later “Daddy,” approached there with volcanic rage; here he is approached with a different mixture of grief and bewilderment. The comparison illuminates both poems, and the distance between them marks the development of a poet finding her true emotional register.
The collection shows Plath working consciously within the tradition. The influence of Yeats is audible in the rhetoric and ambition of certain poems; Theodore Roethke’s presence is felt in the greenhouse imagery and the attention to small natural phenomena as bearers of psychological meaning. This is not weakness — influence and dialogue with tradition are how poets learn — but it means that the collection has a quality of formal performance that Ariel transcends. Plath is demonstrating, here, that she can do what the tradition requires. In Ariel, she will demonstrate what only she can do.
Among the collection’s finest poems: “Medallion,” “Black Rook in Rainy Weather,” and “Mushrooms” — the last of which manages to be ominous, funny, and politically resonant simultaneously, a combination entirely characteristic of Plath’s mature gifts. The Colossus is the necessary preparation for everything that followed.
Our rating: 4.3/5
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "The Colossus and Other Poems" about?
Plath's debut poetry collection, published when she was twenty-seven, reveals a poet of extraordinary technical command working in the shadow of her influences — Yeats, Dylan Thomas, Roethke — and beginning to discover the voice that would produce Ariel.
What are the key takeaways from "The Colossus and Other Poems"?
Technical mastery is the foundation on which authentic voice is built — Plath's later freedom required this earlier discipline The father figure that dominates Ariel is already present here, differently handled A first collection reveals a poet's influences in ways the mature work has absorbed and transformed
Is "The Colossus and Other Poems" worth reading?
The Colossus reveals Plath before she became Plath — technically accomplished, formally disciplined, working within inherited traditions while beginning to strain against them. Essential for understanding how Ariel's explosion was prepared, and valuable in its own right for poems of lasting distinction.
Ready to Read The Colossus and Other Poems?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: