Editors Reads Verdict
The rare second volume that surpasses its predecessor in moral seriousness — Ness forces his protagonists and readers into genuine ethical complexity that most YA fiction deliberately avoids.
What We Loved
- The alternating Todd/Viola perspectives force readers to hold two incompatible moral frameworks simultaneously
- Ness does not allow either side in the conflict to be simply right — both commit atrocities, both believe they are justified
- The question of how good people become instruments of oppression is explored with an honesty unusual in fiction for young readers
Minor Drawbacks
- The sustained moral bleakness is more demanding than most YA — Ness offers very little comfort
- The ending is another cliff-hanger, so readers should have the third volume ready
Key Takeaways
- → Institutional authority specializes in making atrocity seem like administration — the horror of following orders is not ignorance but complicity
- → Both sides of a violent conflict can be genuinely wrong at the same time — the absence of a morally correct side is not moral relativism
- → Love under pressure reveals character: how people treat those they love when the cost of loving them rises is the true test
| Author | Patrick Ness |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Candlewick Press |
| Pages | 519 |
| Published | September 1, 2009 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Young Adult, Science Fiction, Dystopian Fiction |
The Ask and the Answer Review
The Ask and the Answer is the second volume of Patrick Ness’s Chaos Walking trilogy, and it is the point where Ness reveals that he is writing something considerably more ambitious than the dystopian adventure his first book suggested. Where The Knife of Never Letting Go was a survival narrative — Todd and Viola running, relentlessly, through a world that wanted to kill them — its sequel slows down, separates its protagonists, and forces both of them (and the reader) into genuine moral complexity.
Todd has arrived in Haven, the city he has been struggling to reach across two continents, only to find it under the occupation of Mayor Prentiss — a man of terrifying intelligence and total moral flexibility who has systematically crushed resistance. Viola is captured by a resistance movement. Each narrative follows the character as they are drawn, step by step, into doing things they would not have done at the novel’s outset: Todd as an instrument of authoritarian order, Viola as an instrument of a resistance that does not always distinguish itself from the power it opposes.
Ness’s achievement is refusing to resolve this into the comfortable moral arithmetic of most dystopian fiction. The resistance is right to resist; it is also brutal and capable of atrocity. The mayor is wrong in everything he does; he is also occasionally correct in his analysis of how power works. Todd and Viola make understandable choices that are also terrible choices, and Ness insists that we hold both truths simultaneously. It is morally demanding fiction in the very best sense — the kind that expands the reader’s understanding of how good people become instruments of harm.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "The Ask and the Answer" about?
Todd and Viola are separated in a city under brutal occupation. As each is drawn into opposing sides of a conflict, Ness refuses to offer the comfortable moral clarity of most dystopian fiction — both resistance and authority use violence, and both claim necessity.
What are the key takeaways from "The Ask and the Answer"?
Institutional authority specializes in making atrocity seem like administration — the horror of following orders is not ignorance but complicity Both sides of a violent conflict can be genuinely wrong at the same time — the absence of a morally correct side is not moral relativism Love under pressure reveals character: how people treat those they love when the cost of loving them rises is the true test
Is "The Ask and the Answer" worth reading?
The rare second volume that surpasses its predecessor in moral seriousness — Ness forces his protagonists and readers into genuine ethical complexity that most YA fiction deliberately avoids.
Ready to Read The Ask and the Answer?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: