Editors Reads Verdict
Huxley's most ambitious novel is a formal experiment that mostly succeeds — a fugue of ideas and characters that captures London's interwar intellectual world with devastating satirical precision.
What We Loved
- The formal ambition — a novel structured like counterpoint in music — is genuinely realised
- The satirical portraits, especially of D.H. Lawrence as Mark Rampion, are sharp without being cruel
- The sheer range of ideas in play — biology, fascism, socialism, art, sexuality — gives the novel an extraordinary texture
Minor Drawbacks
- The large cast of characters makes emotional investment difficult — Huxley is often more interested in their ideas than their lives
- At 600 pages, the novel's formal ambitions occasionally make it feel laborious
Key Takeaways
- → The life of the mind and the life of the body are not easily reconciled — almost every character in the novel fails to integrate them
- → Political idealism, whether fascist or socialist, is usually a sublimated form of personal frustration
- → The novel as a form is capable of holding more simultaneous perspectives than any other art
| Author | Aldous Huxley |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Dalkey Archive |
| Pages | 608 |
| Published | January 1, 1928 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Literary Fiction, Modernist Fiction, Social Fiction |
Point Counter Point Review
Point Counter Point is Huxley’s most formally self-conscious novel, and one of the most formally ambitious English novels of the 1920s. Published in 1928, it takes as its structural model the fugue — multiple melodic lines developed simultaneously, returning and varying on their themes — and attempts to apply that principle to a novel with more than thirty named characters moving through the London of the mid-decade. The result is a book that is simultaneously a roman à clef, a satirical comedy of intellectual life, and a meditation on the impossibility of the unified self.
The novel’s pivot character is Philip Quarles, a novelist who keeps a journal about the novel he is trying to write — a novel structured like counterpoint in music, tracking multiple characters and themes simultaneously. This is of course the novel we are reading. Huxley makes the device explicit: Quarles’s journal entries about novelistic theory double as a commentary on the text itself. It is a degree of self-consciousness unusual for 1928 and still striking now, less because it is clever than because it is genuinely illustrative — the discussion of form is not decoration but argument.
The cast is drawn largely from Huxley’s social world: Philip and Elinor Quarles shadow Huxley and his wife Maria; Burlap, the predatory literary editor, is a portrait of John Middleton Murry; and above all, Mark Rampion — the painter who insists on the unity of mind and body, who rails against the deadening effect of pure intellectualism, who is the novel’s positive pole — is D.H. Lawrence, whom Huxley knew and who was simultaneously his closest intellectual antagonist. Lawrence reportedly disliked the portrait while acknowledging its accuracy.
The satire ranges widely: Everard Webley, the fascist leader, is based on Oswald Mosley and is treated with contempt rather than caricature; the various socialists and intellectuals are shown as people whose political commitments are mostly expressions of private failure. What binds the novel’s many strands is Huxley’s central obsession: the inability of the educated English to live whole lives, to connect their intellectual sophistication with their emotional and physical existence. Almost every character in the novel is fragmented — living in the head, or the body, or the ideology, but never fully in all three at once. Rampion/Lawrence is the exception, which is why he is both the novel’s hero and its most schematic figure.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "Point Counter Point" about?
A roman à clef of London intellectual and artistic life in the 1920s, following dozens of characters through parties and arguments and affairs, structured like a fugue in prose with multiple themes developed simultaneously.
What are the key takeaways from "Point Counter Point"?
The life of the mind and the life of the body are not easily reconciled — almost every character in the novel fails to integrate them Political idealism, whether fascist or socialist, is usually a sublimated form of personal frustration The novel as a form is capable of holding more simultaneous perspectives than any other art
Is "Point Counter Point" worth reading?
Huxley's most ambitious novel is a formal experiment that mostly succeeds — a fugue of ideas and characters that captures London's interwar intellectual world with devastating satirical precision.
Ready to Read Point Counter Point?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: