Editors Reads Verdict
Claire North brings an unusually sharp political intelligence to the Odyssey's neglected half, constructing a Penelope who is not a patient wife but a skilled ruler navigating genuine danger, narrated by a goddess whose own frustrations give the story an ironic double vision.
What We Loved
- Penelope emerges as one of the most compelling protagonists in recent mythological fiction
- The goddess narrator Hera adds layers of irony and divine perspective rarely seen in retellings
- The political machinations on Ithaca are rendered with genuine complexity
- North's prose is distinctive and stylistically adventurous
Minor Drawbacks
- Hera's narrative voice takes some adjustment and may not suit all readers
- The novel's deliberately constrained setting can feel claustrophobic at times
- Readers expecting action in the Odyssean vein may be surprised by the story's quieter register
Key Takeaways
- → Survival under patriarchal constraint requires a form of intelligence rarely recognized as such
- → Waiting, when it is done strategically, is a form of action
- → The stories told about women by their cultures are rarely the stories women would tell about themselves
| Author | Claire North |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Orbit |
| Pages | 384 |
| Published | July 19, 2022 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Mythological Fiction, Literary Fiction, Historical Fiction |
| Difficulty | Intermediate |
| Best For | Readers who loved Pat Barker's Silence of the Girls or Natalie Haynes's A Thousand Ships and want another feminist reckoning with the Trojan War cycle — particularly those drawn to political intrigue and complex female protagonists. |
The Queen Nobody Watched
Homer’s Odyssey is many things — adventure story, homecoming epic, portrait of cunning — but it is not the story of Penelope. She appears in it as the faithful wife, weaving and unweaving her tapestry to forestall the suitors pressing her to remarry, waiting twenty years for a husband who may never return. She is admirable, patient, and almost entirely without interiority. Claire North’s Ithaca corrects this omission with considerable force.
The novel is narrated by Hera, queen of the gods, who takes an interest in Penelope’s situation for reasons that are not entirely altruistic. This choice of narrator is one of North’s most interesting formal decisions: Hera is biased, invested, and occasionally unreliable, which means Penelope is never simply heroized. We see her intelligence and her courage, but also her compromises and her moments of failure. The result is a protagonist who feels genuinely human rather than mythologically idealized.
A Kingdom in Peril
What North excavates in Ithaca is a political crisis that Homer’s epic largely treats as background. With Odysseus absent and Telemachus too young to rule, Penelope is managing a kingdom under conditions of extreme instability. The suitors are not merely romantic nuisances — they are a factional threat to the throne, each backed by political interests and each representing a different vision of what Ithaca should become after Odysseus is declared dead.
Penelope navigates this with the tools available to her: intelligence, dissemblance, the strategic use of femininity as a performance, and an exceptionally clear-eyed reading of who among her household can be trusted. The famous shroud is, in North’s telling, not a simple delay tactic but part of a larger political strategy that requires constant management and adjustment.
North’s Distinctive Voice
Claire North writes with a stylistic distinctiveness that sets her apart from most mythological retellers. Her sentences are rhythmically unusual, her Hera is sardonic and self-aware in ways that create a complex ironic overlay on events, and she is not afraid to let the novel slow down and sit with moments of quiet dread. Ithaca is the first book in a planned trilogy, and it functions as an extended establishment of conditions — which means some readers may finish it feeling that the larger story is only beginning.
That is, in fact, exactly right. But as an opening movement, it is accomplished, distinctive, and entirely its own thing — a Penelope for readers who have always suspected she was more interesting than Homer let on.
Our rating: 4.2/5 — An intelligent, politically sophisticated retelling that rescues Penelope from patient obscurity and installs her as the shrewd ruler she always must have been.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "Ithaca" about?
The goddess Hera narrates the years Penelope spent waiting in Ithaca for Odysseus's return, watching a queen manage suitors, politics, and survival with fierce intelligence while the world assumes she is merely waiting.
Who should read "Ithaca"?
Readers who loved Pat Barker's Silence of the Girls or Natalie Haynes's A Thousand Ships and want another feminist reckoning with the Trojan War cycle — particularly those drawn to political intrigue and complex female protagonists.
What are the key takeaways from "Ithaca"?
Survival under patriarchal constraint requires a form of intelligence rarely recognized as such Waiting, when it is done strategically, is a form of action The stories told about women by their cultures are rarely the stories women would tell about themselves
Is "Ithaca" worth reading?
Claire North brings an unusually sharp political intelligence to the Odyssey's neglected half, constructing a Penelope who is not a patient wife but a skilled ruler navigating genuine danger, narrated by a goddess whose own frustrations give the story an ironic double vision.
Ready to Read Ithaca?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: