Editors Reads Verdict
Into the Water is a more structurally ambitious novel than The Girl on the Train — perhaps too ambitious for its own cohesion. The multi-perspective approach produces genuine atmosphere and some powerful individual moments, but the sheer number of narrators strains the mystery's momentum and makes it difficult to invest deeply in any single thread.
What We Loved
- The drowned women conceit connects past and present with genuine thematic resonance
- The small-town setting is rendered with atmospheric precision
- The mystery's eventual resolution is genuinely surprising and well prepared
Minor Drawbacks
- Too many narrators — eleven perspectives — dilutes tension and makes tracking difficult
- Several point-of-view characters are underdeveloped given the weight placed on their revelations
Key Takeaways
- → The bodies of water in small communities accumulate histories that the living inherit
- → Communities protect certain narratives about their dead in ways that harm the still-living
- → Grief and guilt are frequently indistinguishable from the outside — and sometimes from the inside
| Author | Paula Hawkins |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Riverhead Books |
| Pages | 386 |
| Published | May 2, 2017 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Psychological Thriller, Mystery, Suspense |
The River Remembers
Paula Hawkins followed one of the decade’s biggest debut thrillers with a sophomore novel that took genuine structural risks. Where The Girl on the Train worked through three tightly focused female perspectives, Into the Water multiplies its viewpoints to eleven — a choice that generates both the novel’s distinctive atmosphere and its most significant problems.
The Drowning Pool in the small English market town of Beckford has a long history: women suspected of witchcraft, women who got in the way, women whose deaths were conveniently ruled accidents or suicides. When Nel Abbott, who was writing a book about the Pool’s historical victims, turns up dead in its waters, her sister Jules arrives to collect Nel’s teenage daughter and reluctantly begins to understand what her sister was investigating.
Eleven Voices
The multi-perspective structure is Hawkins’s attempt to capture how a small community processes, conceals, and distorts a death. Each narrator has a partial view, a private stake, and a slightly different relationship to the truth. The ambition is clear: no single person can be trusted, so the reader must triangulate toward the facts from eleven imperfect angles.
In practice, the approach creates as many problems as it solves. Some perspectives are considerably more developed than others, and the reader’s investment is repeatedly interrupted just as it begins to build. The mystery’s forward momentum is frequently sacrificed to the demands of the structural scheme.
What Works
The novel’s genuine achievement is atmosphere. Hawkins renders the Beckford Pool and the town around it with a sense of accumulated female suffering that gives the mystery genuine weight beyond its plot mechanics. The historical context — the actual historical record of women drowned as witches — is woven in with skill, and the thematic connection between past and present deaths is the novel’s most interesting argument.
Nel Abbott, reconstructed primarily through other characters’ memories rather than her own narration, is a compelling absent presence: reckless, brilliant, difficult, and perceptive in ways that got her killed. The crime’s eventual logic, when it arrives, is satisfying and honestly prepared.
A Difficult Second Act
Into the Water is the work of a novelist who did not want to repeat herself — who chose to complicate rather than refine her first novel’s approach. The instinct is admirable; the execution is uneven. Readers who want the compression and momentum of The Girl on the Train will need patience. Those willing to sink into the novel’s atmosphere will find rewards that the thriller scaffolding doesn’t fully advertise.
Our rating: 3.7/5
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "Into the Water" about?
When a single mother turns up dead in a small English town's river — a place with a dark history of women's deaths — her sister arrives to investigate and care for the dead woman's teenage daughter, uncovering secrets that implicate almost everyone.
What are the key takeaways from "Into the Water"?
The bodies of water in small communities accumulate histories that the living inherit Communities protect certain narratives about their dead in ways that harm the still-living Grief and guilt are frequently indistinguishable from the outside — and sometimes from the inside
Is "Into the Water" worth reading?
Into the Water is a more structurally ambitious novel than The Girl on the Train — perhaps too ambitious for its own cohesion. The multi-perspective approach produces genuine atmosphere and some powerful individual moments, but the sheer number of narrators strains the mystery's momentum and makes it difficult to invest deeply in any single thread.
Ready to Read Into the Water?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: