Editors Reads Verdict
Highsmith's most sustained study of suburban horror — Vic Van Allen is one of her greatest creations, a man so controlled he is more frightening than any obvious villain.
What We Loved
- Vic is one of Highsmith's most unsettling and original protagonists
- The suburban American setting is rendered with perfect satirical precision
- The logic of Vic's psychology is internally completely consistent
Minor Drawbacks
- Melinda's perspective is not fully developed — a deliberate choice but one that limits sympathy
- The pacing in the middle sections is slow by design
Key Takeaways
- → Control as a form of violence more disturbing than impulsive murder
- → Suburban respectability as a cover for psychological horror
- → Highsmith's critique of 1950s American domestic life
| Author | Patricia Highsmith |
|---|---|
| Publisher | W. W. Norton |
| Pages | 272 |
| Published | January 1, 1957 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Crime Fiction, Psychological Thriller |
| Difficulty | Intermediate |
| Best For | Highsmith fans; readers interested in psychological studies of marriage and power |
Vic Van Allen lives in a pleasant Connecticut suburb, keeps bees, runs a small publishing house, and is, by all observable measures, an excellent husband. He tolerates his wife Melinda’s affairs — her succession of young men brought openly to their house — because the alternative is losing her, and losing her is the one thing he cannot permit.
When one of her lovers is found dead in the town swimming pool, Vic tells his neighbours casually that he killed him. He didn’t. But the claim establishes something about Vic that everyone already suspected: that under the courteous surface of the ideal suburban husband is a man capable of anything. The bluff becomes, gradually, less of a bluff.
Deep Water is Highsmith’s most sustained satirical novel — a portrait of American suburban life as a performance of normalcy under which violence is not only possible but structurally required. Vic Van Allen is more disturbing than any impulsive killer because his violence, when it comes, is entirely controlled, entirely patient, entirely rational. Ben Affleck and Ana de Armas starred in the 2022 film adaptation.
Reading Guides
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "Deep Water" about?
Vic Van Allen is the model suburban husband — except that he allows his wife Melinda to carry on a series of affairs openly, to prevent her from leaving him. When one of her lovers is found dead, Vic lets it be known that he killed him. He didn't — but the bluff establishes something. A portrait of suburban American life as a theatre of controlled violence, and one of Highsmith's most chilling studies in the psychology of a particular kind of man.
Who should read "Deep Water"?
Highsmith fans; readers interested in psychological studies of marriage and power
What are the key takeaways from "Deep Water"?
Control as a form of violence more disturbing than impulsive murder Suburban respectability as a cover for psychological horror Highsmith's critique of 1950s American domestic life
Is "Deep Water" worth reading?
Highsmith's most sustained study of suburban horror — Vic Van Allen is one of her greatest creations, a man so controlled he is more frightening than any obvious villain.
Ready to Read Deep Water?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: