Editors Reads Verdict
More interior and more complex than Birdsong, with a protagonist whose journey is as much psychological as physical — Faulks's best female characterization and a serious treatment of collaboration and resistance in Vichy France.
What We Loved
- Charlotte herself is one of Faulks's most fully realized characters — her self-discovery is genuine and not predetermined
- The Vichy France sections are historically careful and morally honest about the range of behavior under occupation
- The prose has the same quality as Birdsong without repeating its effects
Minor Drawbacks
- The novel's pace is deliberately measured in ways that some readers find slow
- The love story element is secondary to the historical and psychological concerns, which may disappoint readers coming from Birdsong
Key Takeaways
- → Occupation forces ordinary people into moral choices for which peacetime life offers no preparation
- → Identity can be constructed in exile in ways that would be impossible in one's original context
- → Collaboration and resistance exist on a spectrum, and most people under occupation exist somewhere in the compromised middle
| Author | Sebastian Faulks |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Vintage |
| Pages | 399 |
| Published | September 1, 1998 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Literary Fiction, Historical Fiction, War Fiction |
Charlotte Gray Review
Charlotte Gray is the third volume in Sebastian Faulks’s loose French trilogy — following The Girl at the Lion d’Or and Birdsong — and it is both the most interior and the most politically complex of the three. Where Birdsong concerned itself with the experience of men in the trenches of World War I, Charlotte Gray examines the experience of France under German occupation, filtered through the consciousness of a young Scottish woman who arrives in Vichy France in 1942.
Charlotte Gray goes to France nominally to find her RAF boyfriend Peter Gregory, who has gone missing after a bombing mission. But her stay in the village of Lavaurette in the Languedoc region becomes something very different — an immersion in the daily moral texture of occupied life, where collaboration and resistance are not the clear-cut alternatives of postwar mythology but a continuous spectrum of small choices made by people trying to survive.
The novel is Faulks’s best female characterization. Charlotte is not a heroine in any conventional sense — she is somewhat remote, somewhat unreliable as a narrator of her own emotions, and the journey she makes is primarily psychological rather than dramatic. What she discovers in France is partly about the French, and partly about herself: what she actually wants from her life, what she is capable of, what the story she has been telling herself about her relationship with Gregory has elided.
The historical sections are carefully researched and morally honest. The deportation of Jewish children from the Languedoc region — an event that the novel depicts with quiet, devastating precision — is presented not as a German import but as a French administrative action, and the range of responses from the village’s inhabitants covers collaboration, active resistance, and the large middle ground of people who didn’t actively participate in either.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "Charlotte Gray" about?
A young Scottish woman goes to occupied France during World War II ostensibly to find her missing RAF boyfriend, but discovers more about herself and the French under occupation than she expected. The third volume of Faulks's loose French trilogy, following Birdsong.
What are the key takeaways from "Charlotte Gray"?
Occupation forces ordinary people into moral choices for which peacetime life offers no preparation Identity can be constructed in exile in ways that would be impossible in one's original context Collaboration and resistance exist on a spectrum, and most people under occupation exist somewhere in the compromised middle
Is "Charlotte Gray" worth reading?
More interior and more complex than Birdsong, with a protagonist whose journey is as much psychological as physical — Faulks's best female characterization and a serious treatment of collaboration and resistance in Vichy France.
Ready to Read Charlotte Gray?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: