Editors Reads Verdict
Remarque's most morally courageous novel — the one that insists on the humanity of the ordinary German soldier and the tragedy of his situation, in a literary climate that found such insistence uncomfortable, and does so without excusing or minimizing the war Germany was fighting.
What We Loved
- The moral balance is extraordinary — Remarque gives Ernst Graeber full humanity without absolving Germany of what it was doing
- The three weeks of leave — the love story, the bombed city, the precarious normalcy — are rendered with aching precision
- The Eastern Front sections have a documentary authority: Remarque understood the specific horror of that campaign
- The novel addresses a subject almost no serious literature had touched: the inner life of the ordinary German soldier in World War Two
Minor Drawbacks
- The ending, while honest, is abrupt in a way that feels designed rather than earned
- Some characters in the leave sections are underdeveloped relative to the emotional weight they are asked to carry
Key Takeaways
- → The ordinary soldier who fights in an unjust war is not the same as the architects of that war — moral responsibility has gradations
- → Three weeks of ordinary life — love, warmth, the possibility of a future — can coexist with the full knowledge that the three weeks will end
- → The bombed city is as much a casualty as the dead soldiers — the destruction of a civilization is not only the destruction of lives
- → History does not wait for personal conclusions — the private story ends when the historical machinery demands it
| Author | Erich Maria Remarque |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Fawcett |
| Pages | 378 |
| Published | January 1, 1954 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Classic Fiction, German Literature, War Fiction |
A Time to Love and a Time to Die Review
Ernst Graeber is a German soldier on the Eastern Front in 1943, fighting a war that is already being lost, in conditions that Remarque describes with the same flat, precise refusal of sentimentality that made All Quiet on the Western Front devastating. The Eastern Front of 1943 is different in every respect from the Western Front of 1917 — the scale, the cold, the ideology of the German occupation, the specific brutality of a war whose German prosecution was organized around racial annihilation rather than merely territorial conquest. Remarque does not obscure these differences. He gives his German soldier full humanity without giving him ignorance.
Ernst receives three weeks’ leave and returns to his German city to find it bombed beyond recognition. The city of his childhood — the streets, the buildings, the institutions that defined his formation as a person — has been reduced to rubble by Allied bombing, and the rubble is still smoldering. His parents are missing, presumed dead. Everything he is returning to has been destroyed. In the ruins, he meets Elisabeth Kruse, a girl he barely knew before the war, whose father has been taken by the Gestapo, and they fall in love with the urgency of people who understand that they have three weeks.
The love story is Remarque at his most direct: the courtship, the marriage, the brief domesticity of rented rooms and shared meals in a city that is more ruin than city — all rendered with the precision and warmth that the context makes heartbreaking. Ernst and Elisabeth marry knowing that the three weeks will end and that what comes after them is almost certainly Ernst’s death. They do it anyway. The novel is not a refutation of this logic but an examination of it: the choice to love in full knowledge of the consequences is the only form of freedom available to people whose larger choices have been made for them by the historical machinery of the Third Reich.
The title’s Biblical echo — from Ecclesiastes, “a time to love and a time to die” — is not ironic but exact. Remarque is not saying that love and death are accidentally concurrent in this novel; he is saying that the situation of the young German soldier in 1943 is precisely the situation Ecclesiastes describes: all things in their time, and this is the time for both. The ending, in which Ernst is killed immediately upon returning to the front — shot by a prisoner he had just released, in one of those moral ironies that war produces without design — is not a twist but a completion: the time for dying has arrived.
Our rating: 4.2/5 — Remarque’s most morally ambitious novel, and the one that demanded the most courage to write: the claim that the ordinary German soldier was a human being deserves its place in the literature of the Second World War.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "A Time to Love and a Time to Die" about?
A German soldier on the Eastern Front is given three weeks' leave, returns to his bombed city, falls in love, marries, and must return to the front. Remarque's most compassionate novel about the Second World War gives a German protagonist genuine humanity in a story almost no fiction had attempted: the ordinary German soldier who is neither hero nor monster, simply a man caught in what his country has done.
What are the key takeaways from "A Time to Love and a Time to Die"?
The ordinary soldier who fights in an unjust war is not the same as the architects of that war — moral responsibility has gradations Three weeks of ordinary life — love, warmth, the possibility of a future — can coexist with the full knowledge that the three weeks will end The bombed city is as much a casualty as the dead soldiers — the destruction of a civilization is not only the destruction of lives History does not wait for personal conclusions — the private story ends when the historical machinery demands it
Is "A Time to Love and a Time to Die" worth reading?
Remarque's most morally courageous novel — the one that insists on the humanity of the ordinary German soldier and the tragedy of his situation, in a literary climate that found such insistence uncomfortable, and does so without excusing or minimizing the war Germany was fighting.
Ready to Read A Time to Love and a Time to Die?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: