Editors Reads Verdict
A short, provocative book that makes its argument efficiently and honestly — the evidence for the tribal belonging thesis is real, the implications are disturbing, and Junger is honest about what the argument cannot explain.
What We Loved
- The argument is clear, well-evidenced, and genuinely counter-intuitive without being contrarian
- At 168 pages the book says exactly what it needs to say and stops
- The historical examples — Blitz-era London, Siege of Sarajevo — are precise and illuminating
Minor Drawbacks
- The argument is made at the level of the hypothesis — Junger acknowledges it cannot fully explain all the data
- The proposed responses to the problem are necessarily vague
Key Takeaways
- → PTSD may be partly a symptom of returning to a society that cannot offer the tribal belonging that combat communities provided
- → Shared hardship and genuine mutual dependence create social bonds that affluence and comfort cannot
- → Blitz-era London had lower rates of depression and mental illness than peacetime London — adversity, shared, is different from adversity endured alone
| Author | Sebastian Junger |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Twelve |
| Pages | 168 |
| Published | May 24, 2016 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Non-Fiction, Psychology, Sociology |
| Difficulty | Beginner |
| Best For | Veterans, mental health professionals, and anyone interested in why modern wealthy societies produce such high rates of depression and disconnection. |
The Paradox
Veterans who served in combat zones — who experienced genuine danger, genuine deprivation, the genuine possibility of death — often report that they miss it. Not the killing, not the fear, but the community: the intensity of relationships, the shared purpose, the sense that what you did mattered to the people around you and that they would die for you as you would for them.
Returned to civilian life — to families who love them but cannot understand, to communities that have not noticed they were gone, to work that does not feel consequential — many of them struggle. The PTSD rates in modern armies are not fully explained by combat exposure. Something else is happening.
The Tribal Argument
Junger’s thesis, developed from his reporting in Afghanistan and from evolutionary psychology research, is that humans evolved to live in small groups with genuine interdependence — where your survival depended on the survival of the group and the group knew it. This produces specific neurological and social effects: heightened attention, stronger relationships, clarity of purpose. Modern wealthy societies cannot provide this. We have solved the problems of survival and in doing so have eliminated the conditions that made human life feel most worth living.
The historical evidence he marshals is compelling: disaster communities (the Blitz, the Siege of Sarajevo) consistently report paradoxical well-being during the crisis and depression afterward. The crisis provides what ordinary life does not.
Our rating: 4.2/5 — A short, honest, and genuinely provocative book about what wealthy modern societies have lost in solving their survival problems.
Reading Guides
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "Tribe" about?
Why do soldiers miss war? Why do PTSD rates in modern armies exceed those of many historical conflicts? Junger argues that humans evolved to live in small, interdependent tribes with shared purpose and genuine mutual dependence — and that wealthy modern societies cannot provide this, producing alienation, depression, and the specific tragedy of veterans who find civilian life unbearable after combat.
Who should read "Tribe"?
Veterans, mental health professionals, and anyone interested in why modern wealthy societies produce such high rates of depression and disconnection.
What are the key takeaways from "Tribe"?
PTSD may be partly a symptom of returning to a society that cannot offer the tribal belonging that combat communities provided Shared hardship and genuine mutual dependence create social bonds that affluence and comfort cannot Blitz-era London had lower rates of depression and mental illness than peacetime London — adversity, shared, is different from adversity endured alone
Is "Tribe" worth reading?
A short, provocative book that makes its argument efficiently and honestly — the evidence for the tribal belonging thesis is real, the implications are disturbing, and Junger is honest about what the argument cannot explain.
Ready to Read Tribe?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: