Where to Start with Napoleon Hill: A Reading Guide

Napoleon Hill (1883–1970) was an American self-help author whose most famous book grew from a commission by Andrew Carnegie to interview the wealthiest and most successful Americans of the early twentieth century and identify the common principles of their success. The research took twenty years. Think and Grow Rich was published in 1937, during the Great Depression, and sold 20,000 copies in its first year. It has since sold more than 100 million copies worldwide and is widely regarded as the text that created the modern self-help genre — the book that every subsequent motivational and success writer is, in some sense, responding to.

Where to Start: Think and Grow Rich (1937)

The essential Napoleon Hill — and the foundational text of modern success literature. Think and Grow Rich opens with a premise that its critics find preposterous and its admirers find liberating: that riches begin in the mind, that achievement is preceded by a particular quality of thought, and that the difference between the people who achieve significant goals and those who do not is primarily a difference in the character and intensity of their desire.

This is not a mystical claim in the way Hill sometimes makes it sound. Stripped of the book’s dated metaphysical framing, it makes a psychological argument that decades of subsequent research have partially validated: that the intensity and specificity of a goal affects the likelihood of achieving it; that belief in the possibility of an outcome changes the behaviours one undertakes toward it; and that persistence — continuing to act toward a goal after repeated failure — is a more reliable predictor of outcome than talent, intelligence, or opportunity.

The chapter on Desire is the book at its most compelling. Hill opens with the story of Edwin Barnes, who wanted to become a business partner of Thomas Edison — not an employee, a partner — and who arrived at Edison’s laboratory with no money, no credentials, and no qualifications except his conviction. He worked for Edison for five years, doing whatever he was given, until an opportunity appeared that others had overlooked: Edison’s Ediphone dictating machine, which every Edison salesman believed was unsellable. Barnes recognised the opportunity and sold it successfully, beginning the partnership he had always intended. Hill’s point is that the desire was not vague aspiration — it was a consuming commitment that organised Barnes’s attention and action until the opening appeared.

The chapter on Specialised Knowledge is the book’s most practically durable. Hill distinguishes between general knowledge — broad education, accumulated facts — and specialised knowledge in a specific domain, applied to a defined purpose. His argument that specialised knowledge is more valuable than general knowledge in building wealth has been validated by virtually every study of high performance in professional domains since. The adjacent point — that self-education in a specific field is both possible and sufficient, and that formal credentials are less important than mastery — was heterodox in 1937 and has become considerably more widely accepted since.

The chapter on Persistence is the most emotionally resonant. Hill uses the metaphor of digging for gold three feet from the deposit and giving up — an image that has become the book’s most frequently quoted passage — to make the argument that most failures occur just before the breakthrough point. He is careful not to make this into simple optimism; he acknowledges that persistence without adjustment is stubbornness, not persistence. But the central observation — that the people who succeed are often not more talented or better situated than those who don’t, but are simply still present and still working when the opportunity finally appears — is one that almost anyone who has achieved something difficult will recognise.

The book’s weaknesses are real and should be engaged with directly rather than dismissed or minimised. The Master Mind concept — that a group of minds focused on a single goal creates a third, superior mind — is interesting as a description of collaboration but is dressed in pseudo-scientific language about mental vibrations that is simply wrong. Many of Hill’s historical claims about his conversations with Carnegie, Edison, Ford, and others cannot be verified. And the world the book was written in — predominantly male, implicitly white, with a specific economic context that does not map onto the early twenty-first century — is present throughout and should not be read past.

Read critically, with awareness of both its durable insights and its significant limitations, Think and Grow Rich remains a genuinely useful study in the psychology of achievement and the beliefs that separate people who reach ambitious goals from those who do not.

Reading Napoleon Hill

Think and Grow Rich is Hill’s essential and most enduring book. It stands alone and is best approached as historical context for modern self-help literature and as a study in the psychology of achievement.

For the full Napoleon Hill bibliography, reviews, and biography, visit the Napoleon Hill author page on Editors Reads.

Affiliate disclosure: Links to Amazon on this page are affiliate links. We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.